App Review: iGo My Way 2009 – North America

I Go My Way

(iGo My Way 2009 – North America For more Forum Reviews, see the TiPb iPhone App Store Forum Review Index!)

iGo My Way [$79.99 - iTunes link] is the fourth turn-by-turn app I have reviewed. As with the other three, I have used the app around town as well as planning for a long trip (the same trip I have taken with the others). It generally suggested very reasonable routes, it had the vast majority of POI’s that I was looking for (in fact, I don’t recall a single instance where I couldn’t find something). So how did it compare in the long distance travel?

In the interest of full disclosure, I received a promo code for this app.

Let me start off by saying that I found the interface a little difficult at time. When you start, there is a screen with three main buttons and a map. Tapping the map at the top brings you to your current route and directions. The other three buttons are destination (to program a route), my route (for details on your current route), and settings. Maybe it is just me, but at times I found the layout a little less that intuitive. If I wanted to alter my route, for example, I kept going into “destination” instead of “my route”. While I am sure I would have eventually learned the different buttons, it didn’t strike me as the most obvious layout.

To program a route, you can go into desintation. From there you can select an address, a point of interest, a location on a map, of a list of favorites. In addition, you have your route history at the bottom of the screen. Unfortunately, there was no contact integration. I did find the interface for choosing a destination based on address to be very straightforward – you choose the state, city, street, etc. At any point you can go back and change any of the options. The POI database was very complete (as complete as any of the other apps I have seen), and choosing a point of interest was another straightforward process.

Once your route is calculated (based on preferences), you can make changes like selecting various route alternative. It includes shortest, economical, easiest, and fastest. One really nice feature is that it shows you the distance and the driving time for each of these, and you can select back and forth to see how they look on the map. I wish the display map had more details instead of just a red line showing your route – city names, highway names, or things like that would be appreciated. One nitpick – I had a default “shortest route” option selected. But when I compared with other routes, sometimes the fastest route was listed as many as 10 miles shorter than the shortest route (see the image below). Ummm…need to work on those routing programs!!

You can also choose to look at places around the destination, where it will give you a list of POI near your planned destination. Lastly, you can change any of your route settings (such as vehicle from car to taxi, bicycle, bus, etc). You can choose different preferences (avoid toll roads, avoid ferries) at this point as well. At any time, you can come back to the “my route” screen to get these options again.

Unfortunately, there were limited options to preview or browse your route. You couldn’t do anything aside from viewing a simple over view map – no listed directions, no detailed summary, nothing like that. There was an option to preview the trip, but it would simply plan an animation of your route – not something you had a lot of control over. You didn’t have any option of travelling “via” a specific road, highway, or city, so you couldn’t plan a multiple itinerary trip.

The settings button allows you to change default settings – sounds and warnings, regional settings, etc. Many of these are things that you only need to access once, but the settings also included the default routing options (route type, avoid/use highways, avoid tolls, etc).

When actually driving, I found the iGo app very good. The maps that are displayed are very detailed, to the point of telling you at times when you may need to switch lanes for an upcoming turn. The app (in general) avoids giving you specific distance estimates, instead telling you that you have “more than 50 miles to go” or “turn in more than 1 mile”. I found this to be beneficial sometimes (like when I am just starting a new leg) but at times I wish they gave me more detailed distance (like when I have five miles or less until a turn). Because there is no way to preview the direction in advance, you also can’t look ahead to see what you will do after the specific leg of the trip. You had limited option for data to display on the map – you could choose from distance left, time left, or ETA (or all three). There was supposed to be an option for an audible speeding warning, but I never heard anything so it was not very effective.

My biggest complaint with the app was starting it up. Multiple times, at least 70% of the time, the app seemed to “freeze” when starting. If I rebooted my iPhone and went right into iGo, I had no problems. But if I ran another app, ANY other app first (voice memo, iPod, anything), the app would freeze and not load about 70% of the time. I don’t know if this is a problem with my iPhone (it is jailbroken) or with the app itself. Right now I don’t seem to be having that issue – but it happened enough times, on multiple days to make it a major concern. I did get around this by installing backgrounder and having the app run in the background. Then, when I wanted to go back into the app, it was already running so I had no problems.

The app also seemed to lose the GPS signal more than any other GPS app I have. It usually found it again within a minute or so, but that didn’t happen to any other GPS app I have tested. The ETA’s seemed to be off for longer distances – at one point it said I had about 70 miles left, and the trip would take about 2.5 hours. Unlike some of the other apps, the screen blank was disabled, meaning the app stayed on even without me doing anything (which I think is good). And like some others, this app could be viewed in landscape mode (a big plus!).

Conclusion

All in all, while I felt the user interface was a little less polished than some others, the quality of the maps, the good POI database, and the options for trip planning were nice pluses for this app. However, the problems with the app starting up prevent me from giving it a high rating. This may be due to my iPhone, and thus may not be an issue everyone else is going to experience, so take that into consideration. But if I can’t even get into an app to run it, pluses (like good maps, nice options) and minuses (no contact integration, shortest route isn’t always the shortest) take a back seat. At $79.99, this is a pricey app, so caution should be used before purchasing (check others to see if they had the same startup issues). As it is, I give it three out of five stars – if I didn’t have the startup problems, I would probably give it three and a half or four stars out of five. (I welcome and will post any comments from the app programmers in response to this review)

Pros

  • Very detailed maps
  • Great side by side comparison of routing options
  • Good POI database

Cons

  • No “travel via” option
  • Some problems with starting the app
  • Route options aren’t logical
  • Limited trip overview options

TiPb Review Rating

TiPb Forums Review: 3 Star App

[gallery link="file" columns="2"]

0
loading...
0
loading...
0
loading...
0
loading...

← Previously

Verizon Set to Unleash New "iDevice iDoesn't" Attack Ads

Next up →

UPDATED: Verizon Attack Ads -- Claim iPhone iDoesn't do What Android 2.0 Droid Does

There are 11 comments. Add yours.

JumpShooter34 says:

Part 1: I personally find this as the best navigation app available on the AppStore after having comparing my Navigon with iGo on my friend's iPhone. The graphics are extremely good-looking, the navigation is very accurate (iGo seems to have u stick to it's own route unless it's sure you've taken another one, therefore it doesn't wander off), the lane assist is well done (not a big solid picture of a lane lin Navigon),

JumpShooter34 says:

Part 2: the route recalculation is very fast, there is a nice one-touch quick-menu and the smart keyboard is nice. The cons are no qwerty keyboard, long start-up times, lack of route settings, no contact access (though I feel this doesn't work in any other GPS app very well, including Navigon) and no iPod support. Even then the app has a beautiful feel to it and it is capable of being the best. Just had to rant about this one, even though I don't have it.

iphone4idiots says:

Chris, why don't you rank the four you have reviewed for us?? I'm sure whomever comes in 4th won't be too mad at ya. I've only tried CoPilot and kicks me out of the app way too much.

Chris Vitek says:

Of the apps I have reviewed, I would rank them in terms of personal preference as follows: Navigon Mobile Navigator, Co-Pilot Live, Sygic MobileMaps, iGo My Way, Gokivo, and AT&T Navigator (reviews of two more are coming shortly). But is due to personal preference (not liking the monthly billings, enjoying the interface, perceived ease of use, etc) than anything else. Ultimately, most of these apps are very similar to each other, offering very similar features. I didn't really experience many bugs or glitches (other than iGo) so I can't address the fact that you are being booted out of CoPilot - it never happened to me.

jtz5 says:

@Chris-
What about TomTom?

Chris Vitek says:

I have not reviewed, or even seen, TomTom. I asked for a promo code and got the (polite) brush off. Or more accurately "we will see what we can do".

cyberbob says:

TomTom was the BIGGEST waste of money I've spent in the iPhone store. I could have bought $100 worth of fart apps and gotten more for my money. No text-to-speech; poor GPS locking; can't keep up with where it's at at any given moment; the maps are choppy and blocky looking compared to those like Navigon and Co-Pilot. I highly suggest waiting until some major updates are released.
Very disappointed in this app and a GREAT reason we should have demos.

Joe the Plumber says:

Why are you reviewing with a jailbreak iPhone?
To provide an accurate review, you should probably be using a "standard" iPhone with the lastest OS.

Dan says:

I own both TomTom and IGo. I paid full price for both. I just used both extensively when travelling in rental car on business in Florida. I use 3GS Iphone (32G) and it is not jailbroken. IGo locked up several times on start up. It also loads VERY slowly on startup. Its collection of resturant POIs was not very good (as compared to what I could find on Yelp, AroundMe, LocalEats, UrbanSpoon and TomTom). In contrast, TomTom worked great. It loaded fast and acquired GPS fast. The voice instructions did not name streets but that convenience is nice, but has never been a must-own for me, especially on an app I use only when travelling on business and renting cars. The voice directions were timely, the routes perfect, the visual excellent. The interface is simple and fast too use. It drained my battery quickly, as these apps do, but not as quickly as Igo. I have only used these two apps, both of which are expensive, but I can presently only recommend TomTom. I would never buy its mount accessory kit, but Amazon has numerous $15 window mounts that will hold an iphone in landscape against a rental car window, and I ordered one today.

Latonya Trochesset says:

I wanted you to know that if your eBook would have reached my hands two years ago, then all chances were that me and my husband savings, that we have laboriously saved in the bank for years, were still be in our possession.

navikolik says:

Garmin navcity,navcity 2010,navcity,navcity 2010.06,garmin,img,gmapsupp.img,garmin türkiye haritası,garmin map,map unl,mapsource,navcity türkiye,başarsoft garmin,garmin 2010.06,2010.06 türkiye
Garmin navcity,navcity 2010,navcity,navcity 2010.06,garmin,img,gmapsupp.img,garmin türkiye haritası,garmin map,map unl,mapsource,navcity türkiye,başarsoft garmin,garmin 2010.06,2010.06 türkiye