iPhone 5s and iPhone 5c round table review: One month later

iPhone 5s and iPhone 5c round table review: One month later

The iPhone 5s and iPhone 5c launched a month ago today, and that means we've had just over 4 weeks to put them through their paces and evolve our first impressions. So, was the iPhone 5s a forward looking upgrade, is the iPhone 5c a popular alternative? One month later, how well have Apple's new iPhones held up?

Peter Cohen

Now that I've had a month with the iPhone 5s, two things have stood out the most for me: Touch ID and the camera. Touch ID is an absolute game-changer, and it's so natural to use that I find myself regularly holding my thumb over the home buttons of iPads and older iPhones just expecting them to work. I found battery life on the iPhone 5s - the first phone I've used from the start with iOS 7 - to be somewhat lacking, at least initially. Turning off Background App Refresh certainly took the sting out.

The A7 processor, paired with OpenGL ES 3.0, is going to help developers make some spectacular looking games. Infinity Blade III is the first example - its texture mapping and visual effects practically rival game consoles. Image processing has been greatly enhanced too - paired with a better camera, the iPhone takes better low-light photos than ever before, and can capture great images in burst mode and video at 120 frames per second, capturing slow-motion action worthy of a much pricier video camera.

If there's a big downside to the iPhone 5s, it's that it doesn't seem quite as stable a platform as the 5 - I've had a lot more app crashes with the 5s than I had with the 5. I attribute this, at least in part, to growing pains associated with the new 64-bit chip architecture in the iPhone 5s, and possibly some lingering weirdness with iOS 7 itself. Either way, I expect Apple is doing whatever it takes to make iOS 7 and the 5s the most stable experience possible for iPhone users.

Georgia

I haven't upgraded to an iPhone 5s yet. I may at some point, but my iPhone 5 is still great. Just like with iOS 7, I haven't seen anything compelling enough to make me rush out upgrade now.

Ally Kazmucha

I picked up both an iPhone 5s and an iPhone 5c on launch day. I'll start by saying the iPhone 5c definitely surprised me when it comes to build quality. This is not a cheap phone. Sure aluminum is higher end and looks more classy, but for $99, people are going to be happy with this thing. It's just an incredibly bold and fun device. I can see myself using the iPhone 5c on a regular basis as a backup phone, or simply as an iPod for testing reasons.

The iPhone 5s is my daily driver and so far, I'm happy with it. I find myself thinking Touch ID isn't that big of a deal, until I pick up my iPad mini and find myself oddly irritated that I have to manually type in a passcode. The convenience factor is definitely there. App Store purchases are nice and easy, when it works that is. For some reason, I still get asked for a password when purchasing apps. Other staff members have this issue as well while others don't.

Either way, I'm happy with my iPhone 5s and feel there's enough there to justify my personal upgrade from an iPhone 5. For me, most of that comes from the camera improvements. I take a lot of photos and in low light, I felt the iPhone was very lacking, especially when it came to motion blur. I don't think it's yet perfect but I feel that for a camera phone, it's one of the best in the industry. And for now, I'm content with that. Fingers crossed for OIS next year!

Joe Keller

I'm one of those people who replaces their phone every two years with their contract, so I came to the iPhone 5s from a 4s. The biggest thing I've noticed about the 5s is how much I'm using it over my previous phone. With the 4s, I would often turn to my iPad to perform a lot of tasks, but now I find that I pick up the 5s instead of the iPad for catching up on Twitter or light news reading.

Touch ID is a real standout feature for me, both for security and iTunes payments. Previously, when I've used a passcode on iOS, it was a simple one. With Touch ID, I've set a more complicated password that I only need to enter in case of a restart. For iTunes, the convenience of Touch ID on the iPhone cannot be overstated. While I was being prompted to re-enter my iTunes password at least twice a day before using Touch ID to download new items, I have been seeing these prompts less and less in the past couple of weeks.

I've found the performance on the 5s to be really solid. I've seen only a few crashes, and apps that have been updated to take advantage of the A7 run really well. Infinity Blade III, demoed on stage during the iPhone 5s announcement, runs smoothly and looks good on the 5s. I don't take many pictures, but those that I have taken are noticeably better to the ones from my 4s.

Richard Devine

I've been using the iPhone 5s since launch day, after a long overnight stint outside the local Apple Store to secure one. And as I've said on a previous iMore Show, I think it's the best phone I've used all year (and I've played around with a good few!)

The 5s is the complete package. Same gorgeous design and amazing construction as the iPhone 5, with improvements that you really can notice. The camera is simply excellent, and was used almost exclusively to capture a recent vacation. Precious memories that not once have I wished I had a 'proper camera' to take. Oh, and try taking better panorama shots with a phone other than with the 5s. It's staggeringly good compared to most things out there.

And of course, Touch ID. I want it everywhere, and I want it yesterday. It works so very well, that despite my previously written about annoyances with it, has value in my daily use far beyond that which I ever could have imagined.

Derek Kessler

This phone is fast. Stupid fast. Modern smartphones are really a marvel of technology when you think about everything that's crammed into them. But in reality there's only one part of the 5s that's changed how I use my iPhone, and that's Touch ID. I've repgrogrammed it a few times as I've realized the multitude of ways that I unlock my iPhone, but this simple layer of security has made things far more convenient for me in keeping my data safe.

The camera is nice, in that it's better, but it's not revolutionary. The minimum focal distance does seem to be improved, and the Touch ID-toting home button still feels delightfully clicking and tactile compared to my older iPhones. But, as an S model, the iPhone 5s isn't a mind-blowing device. It's the iPhone 5, but faster, with a better camera, and a fingerprint scanner. And maybe in gold, if you happen to roll that way.

Rene Ritchie

I was hugely happy with the iPhone 5. Now I'm hugely happy with the iPhone 5s. It's virtually the same phone, only faster - noticeably faster - and with a better camera. I liked the camera after a week. I love it after a month. From the beautifully lit panoramas, to the bursts to simply the better every days, it's once again the best all-around mobile camera I've ever used.

Touch ID has been good too. It occasionally requires me to touch a second time, rejecting the first, but never more than that, and it almost always works immediately. It's so good I want it everywhere. On my iPad. On my Mac. On my house. On my shoes. Every. Where.

I've used the iPhone 5c less as time has gone on, but it's still fun. If the iPhone 5 were still on the market, I'd choose the iPhone 5c over it, no doubt about it. The only question would be which color.

Your iPhone 5s or iPhone 5c: One month later review?

Whether you got an iPhone 5s or an iPhone 5c, we'd love to know what your experience has been. How's your iPhone 5s or iPhone 5c now, one month later?

iPhone 5s

iPhone 5s
Apple's current flagship iPhone with a 4-inch in-cell display, LTE 4G, and BT 4.0 LE. New features include:

Complete review >

Released
September, 2013

Alternatives
iPhone 5c, iPhone 4s

Replacements
iPhone 6 (rumored)
Fall, 2014

Resources
Buyers guide
Help forum

iPhone 5c

iPhone 5c
Apple's first popular iPhone with a 4-inch in-cell display, LTE 4G, and BT 4.0 LE. Fun features include:

Complete review >

Released
September, 2013

Alternatives
iPhone 5s, iPhone 4s

Replacements
iPhone 6 (rumored)
Fall, 2014

Resources
Buyers guide
Help forum

Have something to say about this story? Share your comments below! Need help with something else? Submit your question!

Rene Ritchie

Editor-in-Chief of iMore, co-host of Iterate, Debug, Review, Vector, and MacBreak Weekly podcasts. Cook, grappler, photon wrangler. Follow him on Twitter and Google+.

More Posts

 

11
loading...
0
loading...
52
loading...
0
loading...

← Previously

Apple slipstreams Mavericks GM with new build number

Next up →

Apple releases first iPhone 5s commercial, Metal Mastered, and it's all about the gold

Reader comments

iPhone 5s and iPhone 5c round table review: One month later

19 Comments

Online ordered my 64GB 5s in Space Gray on Sep 20 from AT&T, and had it in hand the following Tuesday. Coming from a 4S, it's a big change, for screen size. Liking TouchID. Getting used to the 4" screen - I actually preferred the 3.5" screen for one-handed use - but liking the extra screen space as well. So far, so happy, but left me wanting for 128GB size and 802.11ac. That gives me no reason to buy the new Airport Extreme, yet.

It is curious that iMore prices the 5s camera so much, when I hear from people that they have hard time telling the 5S stills apart from their old 5's stills. It appears to be more or less the same camera module/lens arrangement, only made more functional with the 5S processing power. Or maybe there are serious quality variations in production models.

My colleague will be getting a 5S when it becomes available later this month, and I will then be able to compare the cameras to see if there is in fact any improvement. It is kind of disappointing Apple does not put more effort in their cameras, given how expensive these phones are. Half-of-the-price mid-range Nokias take better low-light photos -- which is *not* how it ought to be -- and top-of-the-line 1020 takes better photos overall tha nay iPhone. Will iMore ever learn to demand more from Apple instead of always being just happy with whatever compromises they put out? I, as a customer, need more of an actual update next time if they want to get my thousand dollars for a new phone.

Daniel for Windows Phone Central really liked the iPhone 5s camera:

http://www.wpcentral.com/camera-showdown-iphone-5s-lumia-925-and-lumia-1020

(Most humans update every 2 years, not every year, so iPhone 4s vs. iPhone 5s is a more realistic upgrade comparison.)

why is Georgia included in these round tables? the iOS 7 she didn't update, the 5S and 5C she didn't upgrade to. Like c'mon!

Picked up my 5S a couple of weeks after release thanks to Personal Pickup being implemented for iPhone 5S pick ups & I am so spoiled by Touch ID that my iPad & iPad mini right now are just collecting dust on my desk.

I'm very happy with my 5c 32gb, upgraded from a 4s. I really missed the smooth curve of the 3GS,so the plastic back is great for me. I suppose I may have gotten the 5s if it weren't such a hassle, but to tell you the truth, I like the look and feel of the 5c better. Besides, AT

In which he completely fails to make a case for the success for the 5c, focusing instead on how much better than the competition it is, and how its failure is nothing like the failure of the Microsoft Surface RT.

In other words, it is a failure, but a pretty one.

hey rene I currently am an owner of an iPhone 5, and on the borderline considering upgradong to the 5s! do you think that it is worth while to do now or should I wait for next years model the iphone 6?

I'm having a love/hate relationship with touchID. It's awesome when it works, and I too get frustrated when I pick up my old iPhone and hold my finger over the home button and wait for it to unlock... But only a little frustrated as it does nothing, and that's less frustrating than repeatedly telling me "try again" until it finally tells me "enter passcode to enable touchID". It happens VERY often, often enough that I still use a simple passcode.

Sent from the iMore App

These are both fabulous products. It's great to see these two options there's a lot of promise with these two phones.

Only thing I could say, is they're both so new. I haven't been able to find any cases. I'd prefer alternatives to the ones Apple provides.

Just got our iPhones from AT&T. Both are 5s. One for moi and the other for the wife. Both gold. Obviously different cases. Got to say now that I'm getting to play with it I'm digging the screen real estate. Just right for me. Enjoying the LTE speeds and the kicking processor. Definitely a difference over the 4S. Will go through a few more 'honeymoon' days and then the novelty will wear off. Was a no brainier to stay in Apple's ecosystem. Except they do something completely stupid this is where I will stay. Getting a retina iPad mini next.

Sent from the iMore App

I was a little apprehensive about switching from the Android I had grown to love. It was however getting slower, noticeably so. I had experience with a first gen Ipad which still runs as fast as the day I got it. I made the leap to the 5c and have absolutely no regrets. What I like the most is the fact that everything just works...well....It's much more intuitive. I'm a tech guy, and can usually figure out how to do or work anything, but I'm a big fan of any device where the designer actually put some thought into how it was going to be used.