Best Pumpkin Carving Kits heroSource: Comfy Mate

Best Pumpkin Carving Kits iMore 2022

Pumpkin carving kits are a great way to get the family together to do something fun. The best option to pick up is the Sano Naturals 37-piece carving kit with 30 included stencils and two lights. If you're looking for something a bit better, others might fit the whole family in different ways.

Best Overall: Sano Naturals 37-Piece Carving Kit

Sano Naturals 37-piece carving kitSource: Sano Naturals

If you need a carving kit with lots of items included in it, then this kit may be the one for you. With 30 different stencils, two lights, and five tools, there are tons of options to keep your family busy while carving the best pumpkin. The tools are made out of stainless steel, and it has easy-grip handles so you'll be able to control every move.

The stencils are said to run rather small, making them too small for a medium-sized pumpkin. However, if you have kids, it might be best to have a smaller pumpkin for them to carve. Also, you can add multiple designs to a larger pumpkin to keep the fun going.

With 37 different pieces in this carving kit, it'll be perfect for any family, and it will keep you busy for a rather long time. The five included tools are made from stainless steel, so they will be durable and cut through about anything. Plus, the easy-grip handles will ensure that you have complete control over every move.


  • 30 included stencils
  • Two included lights
  • Stainless steel tools
  • Easy-grip handles


  • Stencils are smaller than a medium pumpkin

Best Overall

Sano Naturals 37-piece carving kit

Sano Naturals 37-Piece Carving Kit

Carve like a pro

This set is excellent for any master pumpkin carvers, and it comes with 30 different stencils, so you have a lot to choose from.

Best Value: Powerful 13-Piece Carving Kit

Powerful 13-piece carving kitSource: Powerful

If you don't want to spend a lot of money, but you need more tools than your usual dollar store carving kit, then the Powerful 13 piece kit is exactly what you need. This kit includes 12 tools as well as a free eBook with hundreds of stencils to choose from. It also has a small set of kids carving tools included with this set.

Although there is an eBook of stencils with this kit, there aren't any pre-printed stencils included with it. This may be difficult if you don't have a printer, but you can always go to your local library and print them out before the day you plan to carve. You can also ask any friends or family members to print them for you if you know they have a printer.

If you're able to print out the stencils yourself, this might be the best option for you to save some money. With 12 different tools, including the kids' tool, this will make everyone in your family a part of the fun. Plus, the tools are made out of stainless steel, so they are incredibly durable while carving out every shape.


  • Free eBook of stencils
  • Stainless steel tools
  • Includes carving tools for kids


  • No pre-printed stencils included

Best Value

Powerful 13-piece carving kit

Powerful 13-Piece Carving Kit

Save some dough

If you want a solid set for a cheap price, then the Powerful carving kit is a perfect one to pick up: it includes tools for kids.

Best Alternative: Halloween Haunters 14-Piece Carving Kit

Halloween Haunters 14-piece carving kitSource: Halloween Haunters

Although this one is up there in price, the 14-piece carving kit by Halloween Haunters is a great alternative when it comes to pumpkin carving. The tools are made from stainless steel, and the wooden handles are perfect to help you hold on tight to these utensils. The edges are also sharp, so it easily cuts through the pumpkin, so carving is a breeze.

The best part about these tools is the fact that you can reuse them year after year, and it will still work amazingly. This cuts down on the cost for years to come, so you only have to buy the pumpkins every year. These tools are rather expensive compared to usual carving utensils, but since you can reuse them, that helps even out the price tag.

This reusable toolset is the perfect purchase for some serious pumpkin fun. With stainless steel tools that have sharp edges, these will be a breeze when it comes to cutting and cleaning out your pumpkins. The wooden handles help you keep a tight grip on your tools as well, so those soft edges or jagged teeth are easy to get perfect.


  • Stainless steel tools with wooden handles
  • Sharp edges
  • Reusable


  • Expensive

Best Alternative

Halloween Haunters 14-piece carving kit

Halloween Haunters 14-Piece Carving Ki

Another great choice

These carving tools are perfect for anyone who wants to make a grand, over-the-top pumpkin for the festivities.

Best Ergonomics: Diravo 12-Piece Carving Kit

Diravo 12-piece carving kitSource: Diravo

If you want a set that's more ergonomic for your hands to ensure you get the best lines while carving, then the Diravo kit is your best bet. These tools have imprints for your thumb and fingers to give you the best grip without worrying about it slipping out of your hand. The handles on these tools are also well-made; it's made with solid plastic grips to stop any breaks from happening.

This tool kit comes with a storage case as well, so you can keep them in tip-top shape for years to come. A few comments are stating that the scoop isn't very long, so reaching into the bottom of the pumpkin may be a bit tough. If you don't mind getting down and dirty, then the length of the scoop shouldn't put a damper on your cleaning process.

With the handles of these tools being made for your thumb and fingers, you will get the grip you need to get those perfect lines for your pumpkin's face. It's also made out of high-quality plastic, so it will feel good in your hand and not snap like the cheaper dollar store options. The storage case also means you can take these anywhere you need and also store them safely.


  • Imprints for your thumb and fingers
  • Solid handles
  • Included storage case


  • Scoop is not long enough

Best Ergonomics

Diravo 12-piece carving kit

Diravo 12-Piece Carving Kit

Strong hold

If you want to grab a kit that has a great feel when you're using it, then this set is perfect as it has grips for your fingers.

Best Heavy-Duty: Comfy Mate 12-Piece Carving Kit

Comfy Mate 12-piece carving kitSource: Comfy Mate

Comfy Mate has made a heavy-duty set of carving tools that can withstand any pumpkin you decide to carve. These tools are made from heavy-duty stainless steel to help prevent any sort of break that would happen with other utensils. These are great for both kids and adults alike, so you can freely share them with the whole family.

This is another set that you can reuse for years to come, so you won't have to replace them for quite some time. The other tools included in the kit are a bit too flimsy for pumpkin carving. If you are on the artistic side, they are perfect for poetry, so you can still use them to create something fun with your whole family.

This kit is entirely family-friendly without being cheap and useless for carving. These are made with heavy-duty stainless steel so that they can cut through any pumpkin hide. It's great for kids and adults, so this is a kit you can pass around without wondering if someone will injure themselves. You can use these for years to come and still have durable tools that will continue to cut your pumpkins.


  • Heavy-duty stainless steel
  • Reusable
  • Perfect for kids and adults


  • Wooden tools aren't great for pumpkin carving

Best Heavy-Duty

Comfy Mate 12-piece carving kit

Comfy Mate 12-Piece Carving Kit

Strong and durable

If you're planning to get some heavy-duty tools to use over and over, these Comfy Mate tools are a great choice.

Best High-End: BOOtiful Carving Tools Eight-Piece Carving Kit

BOOtiful Carving Tools eight-piece carving kitSource: BOOtiful Carving Tools

Although these carving tools are a bit on the pricey side, it's well worth the amount that you pay. You get high-quality tools made from stainless steel to ensure that it will cut through anything. These are also reusable, so it helps make the price point worth it since you can use these for years and years.

This also includes a carrying case so you can take them to different parties and also store them away safely. Some comments have said that the blades are thick on these tools, making it a bit harder to cut the pumpkin. However, once you get it started, cutting gets a lot easier, so you just have to get that initial start before things start moving.

With these stainless steel blades, you get an excellent carving kit to show off your skills at any party you get invited to. These are reusable as well, so you can have a high-grade set for years to come. With an included carrying case, you can take these anywhere, and it will make storing them away much easier.


  • Stainless steel
  • Reusable
  • Carrying case


  • Thick blades

Best High-End

BOOtiful Carving Tools eight-piece caring kit

BOOtiful Carving Tools Eight-Piece Carving Kit

Great quality

Although these may be a bit expensive, it's well worth the price you pay for them. It's high-quality and comes with a nice case.

Bottom line

Pumpkin carving is always a great activity to get everyone together and working on one singular task. With the Sano Naturals 37-piece carving kit, there are tons of stencils and fun tools to choose from. This kit has stainless steel tools with easy-to-use grips as well as 30 different stencil choices so everyone can create their own little creatures.

Perhaps you're looking for more tools or something a little more professional. There are tons of options on this list that have high-quality tools or an eBook for more stencils to choose from. No matter which choice you decide to put in your cart, these carving kits will surely bring fun for the whole family.

Credits — The team that worked on this guide

Author: Kennedy Maring Author Picture

Kennedy Maring is a freelancer who loves playing games, her little animal family along with her husband, and the great outdoors. Although she is a nerd through and through, she is looking to complete her cosmetology certificate in the next year.

We may earn a commission for purchases using our links. Learn more.