Beautiful color screen

Fitbit Versa 2

Now with GPS

Fitbit Charge 4

If you're looking for a smartwatch/fitness tracker combo, you can't do better than Fitbit's Versa 2. It doesn't have built-in GPS, but it does sport a beautiful screen, accurate health stats, Alexa, and smartphone notifications.

$200 at Amazon

Pros

  • Gorgeous AMOLED color touchscreen
  • Ample health and fitness data
  • Amazon Alexa built-in
  • 5-day battery life
  • Water-resistant to 50 meters

Cons

  • No built-in GPS
  • It's big

If you can live with the grayscale display, the Charge 4 is the best fitness tracker on the market. With built-in GPS, a swim tracker, and accurate health measurements, the Charge 4 is a slim device that wows.

$150 at Amazon

Pros

  • Built-in GPS
  • Health and fitness data
  • Seven-day battery life
  • Water-resistant down to 50 meters
  • Swim tracking

Cons

  • Grayscale display

Let's break it down

Fitbit Versa2 LifestyleSource: Fitbit

The second-generation Versa came out in 2019, and it has all the bells and whistles of most basic smartwatches. You'll get features like quick replies to texts, notification support for phone apps, storage for up to 300 songs, a massive selection of apps, health and fitness tracking features, a customizable watch face, microphone, Fitbit Pay, and Alexa baked-in.

The Versa 2 excels at fitness tracking, measuring your heart rate, and spitting out short notifications. The sensitive touchscreen allows for quick replies, cycling through apps, setting alarms, and so on. As a tracker, it has the same features you've come to know and love if you've lived in the Fitbit ecosystem for a spell. As a smartwatch, it's not quite up to par with the likes of the Apple Watch. The display is laggy at times, GPS is not hard-baked, app support isn't as well-rounded as the more mature Apple Watch, and the watch is just plain big. If you have small wrists, the Versa 2 will feel gigantic.

Fitbit Charge4 LifestyleSource: Fitbit

The newer Fitbit Charge 4 has many of the features that users have been requesting for years. Finally, we have a built-in GPS. With the Charge 4, you can head out for a run or a hike and leave your phone behind as satellite tracking keeps tabs on your location, distance, and pace. Battery life takes a hit with built-in GPS, but for those of us who don't want to carry a phone during outdoor exercising, it's a long-overdue feature we love.

The Charge 4 looks identical to its predecessor. The inside is where the magic happens here. In addition to GPS, you can track your fitness intensity with something Fitbit calls Active Zones. Basically, it registers various heart rate zones throughout the day to give you a better estimate of calorie burn, energy depleted, etc. The Charge 4 also comes with swim tracking, and now delivers info on swim lengths, distance, pace, and duration. As with all Fitbits, it's water-resistant down to 50 meters.

Fitbit Versa 2 Fitbit Charge 4
Release date September 2019 April 2020
Step counter
Heart rate monitor
Sleep tracking
Swim-proof
Swim tracking -
Built-in GPS -
Active zones -
Smartphone notifications
Female health tracking
Stores music -
Alexa -
On-screen workouts -
Calorie counter
Bluetooth
Display AMOLED touchscreen, color OLED touchscreen, grayscale
Sensors Optical heart rate, accelerometer, altimeter, SpO2, ambient light sensor Optical heart rate, altimeter, accelerometer, SpO2
Microphone -
NFC
Storage -
Battery life 5 days 7 days

The Fitbit Versa 2 and the Fitbit Charge 4 are both capable fitness trackers. You'll get a reliable heart rate monitor, calorie counter, sleep tracker, female health tracker, and stopwatch with both models. The deciding factor is whether you favor built-in GPS and swimming features or want more smartwatch-like functions.

If you want a tracker that will compliment your phone, the Versa 2 is a good choice. You'll get Alexa, notifications, apps, space for music, a microphone, and a big, beautiful screen.

If you're a swimmer, hiker, or runner and have been waiting for Fitbit to implement built-in GPS, you're going to love the Charge 4. It has standalone GPS, 24/7 heart rate monitoring, Active Zones, and swim tracking.

Overall, if I were jumping on the Fitbit bandwagon today, I wouldn't hesitate to invest in the newer Charge 4. For me, the GPS and precise heart rate tracking are a clear win.

Best Smartwatch

Fitbit Versa 2

A solid smartwatch/tracker combo

You won't get built-in GPS, but you will get Alexa, notifications, and all the usual fitness metrics.

Best fitness tracker

Fitbit Charge 4

The newest Fitbit is a winner

It's lacking Alexa, but the Charge 4 comes with every health and fitness metric you can imagine, and it has built-in GPS.

We may earn a commission for purchases using our links. Learn more.