UK government's latest U-turn leaves Apple's iMessage future in doubt

Apple store
(Image credit: Apple)

The UK government has denied reports that it has backed down on its Online Safety Bill, throwing the future of Apple's popular iMessage service into doubt. The latest twist in the saga follows concerns about Apple removing iMessage from the UK. The British government had reportedly requested that the company remove end-to-end encryption on the platform in the name of security. Now, a new report claims that the government is planning to drop the specific measure targeting this, a move the government has since denied. 

The Government had reportedly agreed to drop the Online Safety Bill measure that forced a requirement on messaging services like iMessage and WhatsApp to allow messages to be scanned for illegal content. 

The report from the Financial Times says, “The UK Government will concede it will not use controversial powers in the online safety bill to scan messaging apps for harmful content until it is “technically feasible” to do so, postponing measures that critics say threaten users’ privacy.

A planned statement to the House of Lords on Wednesday afternoon will reportedly mark an eleventh-hour bid by ministers to end a stand-off with tech companies, including WhatsApp, which has threatened to pull its services from the UK over what they claimed was an “intolerable threat to millions of users” security.”

Despite the report from the Financial Times, Technology Minister, Michelle Donelan told Times Radio, as reported by Reuters, that the UK was not backing down from the encryption row and nothing had changed.

"We haven't changed the bill at all," she said.

"If there was a situation where the mitigations that the social media providers are taking are not enough, and if after further work with the regulator they still can't demonstrate that they can meet the requirements within the bill, then the conversation about technology around encryption takes place," she said.

On September 6, the EU announced that Apple was one of six companies deemed a gatekeeper in the digital space, a landmark designation under the EU’s new Digital Markers Act. If iMessage is safe in the UK for now, we could see a world where iMessage works on British shores but not in mainland Europe.

Apple wins in the UK — iMore’s take

The fight for iMessage privacy (in the UK, at least) may not be as over as we'd thought, it seems. The UK Government’s main push for the Online Safety Bill was to protect children and push to find illegal child sexual abuse content. That said, forcing a company like Apple, which prides itself on user privacy and end-to-end encryption, to change its company ethos was always going to be difficult. Apple recently revealed that its dropped its own controversial plans to scan for CSAM material, due to concerns the tech was too intrusive and could be used and abused for other purposes.  

Apple will hope that the UK encryption row is over, especially considering the potential impact of the landmark EU designation that could see the company forced to make significant changes to the way the company operates worldwide.

The iPhone 15, expected next week, is likely to be the first product with USB-C instead of the Lightning charging port, a decision in part forced upon Apple by new EU regulations. There’s a chance that USB-C is only the first of many changes coming to Apple’s products over the next few years if the EU’s landmark designation holds strong.

John-Anthony Disotto
How To Editor

John-Anthony Disotto is the How To Editor of iMore, ensuring you can get the most from your Apple products and helping fix things when your technology isn’t behaving itself. Living in Scotland, where he worked for Apple as a technician focused on iOS and iPhone repairs at the Genius Bar, John-Anthony has used the Apple ecosystem for over a decade and prides himself in his ability to complete his Apple Watch activity rings. John-Anthony has previously worked in editorial for collectable TCG websites and graduated from The University of Strathclyde where he won the Scottish Student Journalism Award for Website of the Year as Editor-in-Chief of his university paper. He is also an avid film geek, having previously written film reviews and received the Edinburgh International Film Festival Student Critics award in 2019.  John-Anthony also loves to tinker with other non-Apple technology and enjoys playing around with game emulation and Linux on his Steam Deck.

In his spare time, John-Anthony can be found watching any sport under the sun from football to darts, taking the term “Lego house” far too literally as he runs out of space to display any more plastic bricks, or chilling on the couch with his French Bulldog, Kermit. 

  • FFR
    “The British government had reportedly requested that the company remove end-to-end encryption on the platform in the name of security.”

    Reply
  • Annie_M
    Oh blimey! :rolleyes:
    Reply
  • iebock
    Forget the UK and the EU and their socialist crap for a minute.

    My question is. If as a US citizen with a US based AppleID (Account) on my iPhone, will my iMessages still be encrypted while I am traveling in Europe given I will be communicating with people back here in the US?
    Reply
  • FFR
    iebock said:
    Forget the UK and the EU and their socialist crap for a minute.

    My question is. If as a US citizen with a US based AppleID (Account) on my iPhone, will my iMessages still be encrypted while I am traveling in Europe given I will be communicating with people back here in the US?


    You have nothing to worry about right now, the encryption is still in place and not bypassed by the eu or the uk.
    Reply
  • graclarkey
    iebock said:
    Forget the UK and the EU and their socialist crap for a minute.

    My question is. If as a US citizen with a US based AppleID (Account) on my iPhone, will my iMessages still be encrypted while I am traveling in Europe given I will be communicating with people back here in the US?
    Errr … it’s actually right-wing Tory crap …

    But to answer your question: yes the E2EE will still be in place. Elsewhere in Europe in the EU too, unless it introduces a similar law in the future, although I doubt it, as nearly all of continental Europe is hooked on the WhatsApp kool-aid — even worse than here in the UK.

    Considering the current UK Government seems to unofficially conduct its business via WhatsApp (which despite being Facebook-in-disguise uses the gold standard of E2EE), I really can’t see how they’re going to take the plunge. Could be the final nail in the Tory coffin at next year’s general election.
    Reply
  • FFR
    graclarkey said:
    Errr … it’s actually right-wing Tory crap …

    But to answer your question: yes the E2EE will still be in place. Elsewhere in Europe in the EU too, unless it introduces a similar law in the future, although I doubt it, as nearly all of continental Europe is hooked on the WhatsApp kool-aid — even worse than here in the UK.

    Considering the current UK Government seems to unofficially conduct its business via WhatsApp (which despite being Facebook-in-disguise uses the gold standard of E2EE), I really can’t see how they’re going to take the plunge. Could be the final nail in the Tory coffin at next year’s general election.

    That’s a great point. What’s app will have to open up their monopoly in the eu and uk .
    Reply