How a fake 2014 Sochi Winter Olympics hacking story is causing real damage to NBC News' reputation

Fake 2014 Sochi Winter Olympics hacking story causes real damage to NBC News' reputation

NBC News would have you believe that the life expectancy of a MacBook Air or Android phone at the Winter Olympic Games is roughly zero, at least when it comes to it being hacked and your financial and other personal information stolen. Anyone with a base level of technical knowledge at all would recognize it as complete and utter bullshit the minute they saw it. Sadly, as many of us who got contacted by concerned family members know, it's far too easy to scare everyone else. Robert Graham of Errata Security calls the report "100% fraudulent":

Absolutely 0% of the story was about turning on a computer and connecting to a Sochi network. 100% of the story was about visiting websites remotely. Thus, the claim of the story that you'll get hacked immediately upon turning on your computers is fraudulent. The only thing that can be confirmed by the story is "don't let Richard Engel borrow your phone".

They didn't name the type of phone, and didn't show an iPhone, which has an amazingly good track record when it comes to preventing malware and other security risks. Phil Nickinson weighs in on the Android aspect on Android Central:

What's more is that Android has safeguards built in by default. While it certainly is possible to hit a link and see a malicious app start downloading, it won't actually install without some other interaction. And one of the first checkpoints is the "Unknown sources" option. If your phone isn't set to install apps from outside Google Play — in other words, "unknown sources," it'll tell you. And in just about every retail phone we can think of, that option is turned on by default. Those are but two layers of security. There are others.

It's a similar story with the MacBook. You'd have to go to a dangerous website, download a malware package, launch it, allow it to bypass Gatekeeper, and give it your admin password in order to install. In other words, you've got to be the failure point, not your computer. And none of that has anything to do with going to Sochi.

Time was mainstream media turned their noses up at bloggers, claiming we were beneath them and weren't "real journalists". And thank goodness for that, given just how crazy a lot of mainstream media has become. I've already expressed my dismay over an excerpt from a former-Wall Street Journal reporter's Apple book, and this just makes a bad day for the Fifth Estate that much worse.

Attracting attention is easy. Doing something worthwhile with it is another thing entirely. NBC could have grabbed us and left us better educated and informed for it. Instead they tried to make us dumber.

NBC's motto used to be "proud as a peacock". What happened to that pride?

Via: Errata Security

(And, given the potential harm of the story, can I tell you how much I don't care that they tore open the MBA box like three year olds on cake-fueld sugar highs?)

Rene Ritchie

Editor-in-Chief of iMore, co-host of Iterate, Debug, ZEN and TECH, MacBreak Weekly. Cook, grappler, photon wrangler. Follow him on Twitter, App.net, Google+.

More Posts

 

21
loading...
0
loading...
100
loading...
0
loading...

← Previously

Flappy Bird: Top 5 tips, hints, and cheats

Next up →

New and updated apps: Mailbox, App in the Air, BBC Sport and more!

There are 22 comments. Add yours.

radiohawk says:

It's not like BSNBC has been accused of real journalism in the past 10 years... Much like Fox news mission has been the prevention of Mr Bush's name being besmerched nbc has assigned themselves the infomercial station for socialist agendas. Once that started they haven't been able to tell the difference between newsworthy and news fakery

Posted via the Android iMore App!

emjayess says:

Yeah, right--mainstream media are about as liberal as the corporations that own them....much less "socialist"! (insert rolling eyes here)

Heckler says:

Not sure we need to play the "socialist" angle on this. NBC hasn't been relevant for many years...

asuperstarr says:

Interesting read!

Sent from the iMore App

93Aero says:

When I saw his piece I just knew it was hype and nothing more. They were infact very light on the details saw right through it.

BLFarnsworth says:

The sad thing is that probably 95% of those who watched it probably believed it... They probably figured that "hey, it's an NBC News story so it must be credible." My, how low NBC has sunk.

heyjohnnybravo says:

Hey now, let's play nice. NBC is the enemy here, not Android.

Posted via the Android iMore App!

willizen says:

Thanks for your constructive comment. In the future, though, keep your thoughts to yourself. Thanks.

richard451 says:

good to see the zealots out to defend nbc

Illustrator Joe says:

The misinformation about Android is just as damaging to Apple in this instance.

GlennRuss says:

Good article. News services are so fast to get the story out, they do not research. It is no longer good journalism, but a ratings war. The days of Walter Cronkite good reporting, are long gone. To bad, and kinda of sad.

Sent from the iMore App

ggore says:

I knew the story was a farce when he ripped open the Macbook Air box.

rodger-bb says:

Someone should show them the proper way to open a MBA box and use there electronics.
Very sad to see such a misrepresentation of the the truth from them.

mikeo007 says:

Thanks Renee. I called this story out from the moment it appeared. Shock 'journalism' like this is a complete joke. What happened to the days of fact-checking a story? *sigh*

jaBBu says:

This was said many years ago and is still relevant today .....

If you don't read the newspaper, you're uninformed. If you read the newspaper, you're misinformed. - Mark Twain

So to bring this into the modern era…

If you don't follow the news, you're uninformed. If you do track the news, you're misinformed.

voenix rising says:

And did you see the way he tore into that MacBook Air box? I wanted to beat him up the side of the head with it. That alone told me the guy was CLUELESS.

Dev from tipb says:

Essentially, the story boils down to:

"If you go looking for trouble, you'll find it"

Sent from the iMore App

that guy with the face says:

That is a perfect summary! I couldn't have said it better myself.

Sent from the iMore App

etaggart65 says:

Did you see the way he tore into that MacBook air box.. Really? Who opens a up a new computer box like ripping into a box of Captain Crunch looking for the prize? Geez. Talk about dramatic effect.

missouri emma says:

Its a really a nice zynga game , its a very interesting game , it can provide online technical support team that can solve your all the problems related to games and and software and hardware.
http://acetecsupport.com/zynga_support.html

Thank you
Missouri emma

Priya Kumari says:

Our company provide you online technical support that offers you the solution of all the problems related to computer hardware and software.
<a href=http://acetecsupport.com/zynga_support.html>Zynga Games Help</a>
Thanks
Aalia lyon