Time to upgrade! Get an iPhone 12 mini + Unlimited Data for $60/mo

  • Forums
  • Shop
  • CES 2021
  • iPhone 12
  • Best VPN
  • iOS 14
  • Nintendo Switch
  • AirPods Pro
tort

Epic Games motion to dismiss some of Apple's counterclaims granted

Apple had tried to argue that Epic's actions were independently wrongful, regardless of whether there was a contract or not.
Stephen Warwick
11 Nov 2020

iPad mini 5Source: iMore

What you need to know

  • Epic Games has had a motion to dismiss some of Apple's counterclaims against the company granted.
  • Apple is countersuing Epic over claims it breached its contract by enabling a new payment method on Fortnite for iOS.
  • A judge has dismissed Apple's claim that Epic's actions were intrinsically wrong, even without a contract.

Epic Games has been granted a motion to dismiss part of Apple's counterclaims against the company in its ongoing antitrust lawsuit.

As noted by Florian Mueller:

#Court throws out #tort-based part of #Apple's counterclaims against #EpicGames https://t.co/4fTiwrEzPe #epic #appstore #ios #antitrust #fortnite #freefortnite #apprising

— Florian Mueller (@FOSSpatents) November 11, 2020

The case called Tuesday via Zoom, as the eyes of most of the tech industry were on Apple's November event, or the Xbox Series X/S launch. As Mueller notes at Foss Patents:

Epic Games just reduced the potential risk it incurs from its antitrust dispute with Apple over its App Store business terms: Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers of the United States District Court for the Northern District of California granted an Epic motion for judgment on the pleadings on some of Apple's counterclaims. As a result, Apple's counterclaims (unless an appeals court revives the ones the judge just threw out) are limited to breach of contract, which Epic already acknowledged in October it would be liable for should it lose its antitrust case against Apple. Punitive damages, which Apple was seeking, are not available on this basis, so they won't have to be discussed at next year's trial.

Mueller notes that the court had always been skeptical of Apple's 'tort-based' arguments and that Apple was likely trying to keep them on the books for a possible appeal.

As noted by Bloomberg, Judge Gonzalez Rogers told Apple's lawyers that this was "a high-stakes breach of contract case and an antitrust case and that's all in my view", further noting Apple couldn't "just say it's independently wrongful."

VPN Deals: Lifetime license for $16, monthly plans at $1 & more

As Mueller notes, these specific claims from Apple stated that Epic's actions went beyond a breach of contract, and could be considered wrong regardless of whether the two had a contractual agreement. Unconvinced, Judge Gonzalez Rogers tossed the claims, meaning Apple's counterclaim will continue against Epic, limited to whether the Fortnite developer acted in breach of contract. In a statement, Apple said:

"We respectfully disagree with the Court's decision and believe Epic's conduct should be actionable under California tort law. It is clear, however, that Epic breached its contract with Apple. For twelve years, the App Store has helped developers turn their brightest ideas into apps that change the world. Our priorities have always been to provide customers with a safe and trusted place to download software and to apply the rules equally to all developers. In ways the Court described as deceptive and clandestine, Epic enabled a feature in its app which was not reviewed or approved by Apple, and they did so with the express intent of violating the App Store guidelines that apply equally to every developer who sells digital goods and services. Their reckless behavior made pawns of customers, and we look forward to making it right for them in court next May.

"Apple also thanks the Court for providing next-generation attorneys the opportunity to argue a motion. We fully support this important policy that gives newer lawyers and those from underrepresented groups meaningful experience in court."

Epic sued Apple, over what it claims are anticompetitive practices and a monopoly on iOS app distribution, earlier this year after it enabled a new payment method in Fortnite on iOS in breach of App Store guidelines. The case is set for trial next year.

Apple releases new limited-edition Apple Watch Series 6 Black Unity
a surprise release

Apple releases new limited-edition Apple Watch Series 6 Black Unity

Apple has just released a brand new limited-edition Apple Watch Series 6 to celebrate Black History Month.

Taron Egerton to star in new Apple TV+ show 'In with the Devil'
TV+

Taron Egerton to star in new Apple TV+ show 'In with the Devil'

A new report says Taron Egerton will star in a new Apple TV+ series called 'In with the Devil' alongside Paul Walter Hauser.

iPhone 12 Pro camera supplier LG sees 43% revenue rise in 2020
bumper year

iPhone 12 Pro camera supplier LG sees 43% revenue rise in 2020

iPhone 12 Pro camera supplier LG InnoTek saw its 2020 revenue rise by 43% on the previous year thanks to the iPhone 12's launch in October.

Love Fortnite? You need these Funko Pop! figures in your life
Victory royale!

Love Fortnite? You need these Funko Pop! figures in your life

Epic Games’ Fortnite has become a gaming and cultural phenomenon buoyed significantly by the Battle Royale craze. With such a meteoric rise, it’s only fitting Fortnite clashes with Funko Pop!

Keep in Touch

Sign up now to get the latest news, deals & more from iMore!

I would like to receive news and offers from other Future brands.

I would like to receive mail from Future partners.

No spam, we promise. You can unsubscribe at any time and we'll never share your details without your permission.

  • News
  • Fortnite
  • iPhone
  • iPad
  • Apple Watch
  • Apple TV
  • Mac
  • Reviews
  • How To
  • HomeKit
  • Forums

Other Categories

  • About Us
  • Newsletter
  • Fitness
  • Apps
  • Gaming
  • Deals
  • Advertising Inquiries
  • Licensing and Reprints
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Android Central
  • Windows Central
  • CrackBerry
  • Thrifter
  • TechnoBuffalo
  • MrMobile
Log in or Sign up
  • t
  • f
  • y
  • i
  • r

Brightness

  • © Future US, Inc.
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Careers
  • Licensing
  • External Links Disclosure
  • Accessibility Statement
  • © Future US, Inc.
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Careers
  • Licensing
  • External Links Disclosure
  • Accessibility Statement