• Forums
  • Shop
  • iPhone 13
  • AirPods Deals
  • iPad Deals
  • Best Apple Watch
  1. Home
  2. /
  3. Opinion

Why Apple went with Face ID instead of in-display Touch ID

Good facial scanning is better than bad fingerprint detection, turns out.
Rene Ritchie
5 Mar 2019

18 months later and while in-display fingerprint sensors have taken a step forward with Samsung's Galaxy S10, they're still not, you know, good.

Andrew Martonik, writing for Android Central:

'll lay it out simply: the ultrasonic fingerprint sensor is better than the optical ones I've used (primarily, the OnePlus 6T), but it is not as fast, accurate or easy to use as a modern capacitive fingerprint sensor. That shouldn't really come as any surprise, as capacitive sensors are a mature technology while the in-display sensors are still relatively new. But it's worth making clear. There is no situation in which the ultrasonic fingerprint sensor has been faster or more consistent than the Galaxy S9's rear-mounted capacitive sensor. That's incredibly unfortunate.

Also:

The only thing detracting from the complete package is the fingerprint sensor. A clear downgrade. It's a real shame that it puts a mark on such an amazing phone. I understand why Samsung did it, but it's interesting that it keeps making biometric decisions that fall short.

— Andrew Martonik (@andrewmartonik) March 5, 2019

Dan Seifert, writing for The Verge:

But it's not as fast or reliable as the traditional, capacitive fingerprint scanner on the back of the S9. The target area for the reader is rather small (though the lock screen will show you a diagram of where to place your finger) and I had to be very deliberate with my finger placement to get it to work.

Even then, I often had to try more than once before the S10 would unlock. I'd just rather have a Face ID system that requires less work to use, or at the very least, an old-school fingerprint scanner on the back of the phone. The S10 does have a face unlock feature, but it's just using the camera to look for your face and compare it to a previous image — there's no 3D mapping or anything. I was actually able to unlock the S10 with a video of my face played on another phone.

Jessica Dolcourt, writing for CNET:

I had issues with accuracy and speed at first, but it's been more accurate since Samsung pushed out an update to reviewers. It seems to work best the more deliberate you are about the placement of your thumb. It'll take a solid second to unlock, and you need to make sure you're actually pressing the screen, not just skimming it.

Others, including the Wall Street Journal and Wired didn't report the same issues, but I've also heard from friends who have it that it's not as good as the previous, non-in-screen sensor. Anecdote isn't data, but it's a tougher problem to solve so it stands to reason it'll take a little time and a few generations to solve it. Look at how long it took standard sensors to become good.

The difference is that Apple isn't into experimenting in public. So, Face ID, rather than a worse Touch ID. At least for now.

I'm on record as saying I think touch-based authentication will return to iPhone at some point. Just not now, not even 18-months later, and not in the way we might expect.

Read Android Central's Samsung Galaxy S10+ review.

Review — Fire Emblem Warriors: Three Hopes is a fun but repetitive return
Garreg Mash

Review — Fire Emblem Warriors: Three Hopes is a fun but repetitive return

Fire Emblem Warriors: Three Hopes allows players to revisit the same characters from Three Houses. However, it's very different and will only be enjoyable if you understand that going in.

iOS 16 makes Shortcuts "much easier" for developers to adopt
Time to add Shortcuts support

iOS 16 makes Shortcuts "much easier" for developers to adopt

At WWDC, Apple introduced updated developer tools for integrating with the Shortcuts app. We asked three app developers about their thoughts on the changes.

Review: Apple Studio Display isn't perfect, but offers surprising goodies
5K

Review: Apple Studio Display isn't perfect, but offers surprising goodies

It has many drawbacks, but the Apple Studio 5K Display is worth considering for those who may be looking for an Apple-branded display.

Check out these Nintendo Switch controllers made for kids
The kids have control too!

Check out these Nintendo Switch controllers made for kids

The right controller can make a big difference in a child's gaming experience and a parent's experience with the equipment. These are the best Nintendo Switch controllers for kids.

Keep in Touch

Sign up now to get the latest news, deals & more from iMore!

I would like to receive news and offers from other Future brands.

I would like to receive mail from Future partners.

No spam, we promise. You can unsubscribe at any time and we'll never share your details without your permission.

  • Opinion
Rene Ritchie

Rene Ritchie

Rene Ritchie has been covering personal technology for a decade. Former editor-in-chief of iMore and Editorial Director for Mobile Nations, he specializes in Apple and related technologies, news analysis and insight. Follow him @reneritchie on Twitter, Instagram, watch his videos on YouTube, and visit him on the web at reneritchie.net.

  • iPhone
  • iPad
  • Apple Watch
  • Mac
  • Apple TV
  • Reviews
  • How To
  • HomeKit
  • Forums

Other Categories

  • About Us
  • Newsletter
  • Fitness
  • Apps
  • Gaming
  • Deals
  • Advertising Inquiries
  • Licensing and Reprints
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Android Central
  • Windows Central
  • Thrifter
  • TechnoBuffalo
  • MrMobile
Log in or Sign up
  • t
  • f
  • y
  • i
  • r

Brightness

  • © Future US, Inc.
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Licensing
  • External Links Disclosure
  • Accessibility Statement
  • © Future US, Inc.
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Licensing
  • External Links Disclosure
  • Accessibility Statement