Accessories

#CESLive: Document Your World with Narrative

Apps

Feedly transitioning to Google+, Facebook, Twitter and Wordpress as preferred login services [updated]

Apps

Reeder 2 hits the App Store completely iPad ready

Apps

Feedly goes pro, gives you more in your RSS for $5 a month

Apps

ReadKit for Mac gets even better with added Feedly support

Apps

ReadKit for Mac keeps your reading together in one fast, stylish place

News

Google Reader deathwatch day one: Final warnings and Feedly and Flipboard frustrations

Apps

Reeder for iPhone update now live, Feedly support arrives in the nick of time

Apps

Newsblur will look after your RSS long after Google has said goodbye

Apps

Looking for life after Google Reader? Here's what you need to know!

News

First look at the new AOL Reader beta, a surprisingly pleasing way to get your RSS fix

Apps

Still looking for a Google Reader replacement? AOL steps up to the plate!

Apps

Feedly launches 'Feedly Cloud,' Newsify updated to support new Google Reader replacement

Apps

Feedly switches on its API, updates its apps, ahead of Google Reader shutdown

Apps

Feedly emerging as a prime candidate to replace Google Reader, Reeder and Newsify to integrate their API

Google spring cleans Reader out of existence, also trashcans some CalDav, Snapseed for Mac

Editorial

X11 and the disturbing trend of Apple removing functionality from OS X

Reviews

Blogshelf II for iPad review: a fantastic way to discover and follow websites and blogs

Apps

Instapaper vs Pocket vs Readability: iPhone read later app shootout

Apps

Google releases Currents, a user-friendly news reader

iChat, iMags, iNews, iFeeds, and iBlog -- TiPb's Top 5 iPad and iPhone iWants!

iwork_20100127

With the launch of Apple's iPad tablet and iBooks eBook purchasing and reading software, Apple has significantly rounded-out their device and content offerings, but TiPb can't help but think a few iApp holes remain, namely iChat, iMags, iNews, iFeeds, and iBlog.

Some of these will likely resonate immediately, others we might need to explain our thinking, but either way what Apple gave us last week and the hype and hyperbole, expectations and exasperations, hopes and howls that proceeded and followed it shows just how much we all think and feel about the iPhone OS platform.

First things first. None of these ideas are new or novel. In fact, most of them have been mentioned from early on and mentioned a lot. We're just looking at where the iPhone, iPod touch, and iPad are today, and listing -- or re-listing -- some of the remaining, wickedly obvious, gaps in their apps.

Second things second. As much fun as we think an iPad version of Mac OS X's Photo Booth would be, we're not going to include anything that would require additional hardware like an iSight webcam. We want it, believe us we do, but we're going to stick with what Steve Jobs showed us on stage last week... for now.

iChat

Seriously, where the [redacted] is Mobile iChat? While Mac OS X power-users might gravitate to third party solutions like Adium, Apple makes sure every one of their computers ships with iChat, and for mainstream Mac users, that's still the go-to app. That it's on every one of Apple's computers, along with Mail and Safari, shows just how core IM (instant messages) are to the internet experience. Yet three generations heading towards four, and we've seen no sign of it for the iPhone -- and now the iPad -- other than the always plentiful Apple patent filings.

There are great 3rd party IM clients for the iPhone in the App Store, no doubt about it. Maybe if there was a Mobile iChat that wouldn't be the case. There are no other email clients or browsers in the App Store by way of worst case scenarios (just embeddable mail and webviews). There are other camera apps and photo viewers, however, weather and stock apps, contact managers and voice recorders, so there's a best case as well.

Apple already has the built-in Messages (formerly SMS) app on the iPhone. Maybe carriers weren't originally keen on the idea of 1st-party threats to their utterly plush text message business but that ship has sailed. Build out or build upon Messages and give us iChat. Give mainstream users base instant message functionality out of the box, with typical Apple simplicity and elegance, and of course the background multitasking that would come with such status. Power users who want more, and are willing to switch to push-notifications, could find other options in the App Store.

And yeah, we're not bringing up iChat Video because we promised not to mention hardware, but you know that they know they we know we'll bring it up again at some point...

ichat_im20090608

iMags

At the iPad announcement we got iBooks, Apple's answer to eBook buying and reading, but what about iMags for magazines? As much as we love our eBooks, we like the idea of getting our weekly or monthly magazines delivered with just as much iTunes automagical goodness.

Going one strep further, how about an iTunes LP/Extra style format then that would allow easy and consistent eMagazines to be produced, seamlessly blending text, video, even music into something readers would be willing to pay for so that publishers can afford to create it. (And you bet we think an iLife '10 with iDVD turned into a super-slick iTunes TuneKit development tool would be a great idea no matter which road Apple chooses to take). Just like indie music, it would let independent writers/publishers get into the game. iZine, if that doesn't make you shudder.

Okay, maybe iTunes isn't set up to handle subscriptions yet and that's the current show-stopper. Apple never pulled that trigger for music and is apparently having trouble getting the TV industry to let them pull it for video. Even season passes for TV series aren't really up to the level of a real subscription service yet.

But Amazon's Kindle is already handling magazines and newspapers (which we'll get to next), and as much as iBooks is an ePub answer to the Kindle Book Store, Apple and the iPad need an answer for eMagazines.

iBooks app for iPad

iNews

While iMags covers weeklies and monthlies, the dailies need a solution just as badly. iNews, or eNewspapers, or whatever is the appropriate term for digital content that "just works" its way onto your iPad at 3am every day -- again just like the Kindle is already doing -- is the other missing piece of the iBooks puzzle.

Sure, Apple has the no less than the New York Times up on stage showing off their prototype iPad app during the introduction, but hundreds of independent apps clogging up our devices -- and the App Store -- is a very un-Apple-like solution. While it would no doubt lead to tons of creativity and variety, Apple prides itself on simplicity and UI consistency. (Otherwise why not just sell the OS and let OEMs and do-it-yourselfers build their own Macs, right?)

Maybe Apple is just taking its time, starting off with books the way they started off with music in iTunes, and they're already intending to add magazines and newspapers the way iTunes has added movies and TV shows. Sure, no matter how big they are, Apple is still only one company and they have to choose how to spend their finite engineering resources. Hopefully they'll choose to spend some on those subscription services, because we can't help but think they'd be killer, especially for periodicals.

iFeeds

Say what you want about desktop Safari RSS, but at least desktop Safari has native RSS. Mobile Safari pushes RSS out to a webapp so abandoned it still uses .mac in its URL (which Apple changed to MobileMe back in summer of 2008 with the launch of the iPhone 3G/iPhone 2.0). Just like with IM, there are a lot of great RSS clients in the App Store, and they do something Apple would likely not choose to do -- sync with the 900lbs gorilla that is Google Reader. So, we hope they don't go anywhere. But for casual news reading, a built-in Apple client, even a native extension to Mobile Safari would be nifty, if only and again for background multitasking.

See, on desktop Safari our RSS just updates in the background and new articles are brought down and ready and waiting for us to peruse immediately and at our leisure. App Store apps launch, contact Google Reader, check status, start to sync or populate a list view from web data, and then and only then can we start reading. (Or they just function as a skin for a WebApp and then we can just as easily add Google Reader proper to our Home Screen).

This one is a tougher sell, no doubt about it. Mainstream users don't use RSS and a certain segment of geeks is moving from RSS to social networks like Twitter and Facebook to crowd-source and crowd-sort their news. The former is something Apple just doing it could fix, especially with a few pre-populated, and popular, feeds ready to go. The latter still strikes us as far too subject to happenstance (if you stop following for a couple hours to nap or watch a movie, a story that matters to you could be plowed away by several newer ones that matter more to others).

features-rss-sorting-20090528

iBlog

And we can already hear you complaining this one is thinner than an iPod touch, but again bear with us. As much as the iPad, and to the same extent the iPhone, is focused more on consumption of content than creation, but as the iPad iWork apps themselves show, we're going to need some creation, including for web-based services.

If iDVD is going to be reborn as an easy iTunes LP/iTunes Extras development tool, why can't iWeb be reborn to better handle modern web 2.0 content creation? Rather than static pages, blogs and micro-blogs are the web site creation mediums of today. There are dedicated apps for several of the more popular blogging platforms already on the iPhone App Store, but they're dedicated apps and the web is more distributed than ever.

Microsoft makes Windows Live Writer and on Mac OS X there are a couple great applications that let you write for many of the most popular blogging platforms. Apple's been accused of not "getting" social media for a long time but it's getting to the point where it just has to be gotten.

iLife '09 for Mac contained iPhoto, iMovie, GarageBand, iWeb, and (hidden away) iDVD. We've already seen iWork's Pages, Numbers, and Keynote for iPad. We've seen Photos for iPhone, iPod touch, and iPhone. I'm sure many would like a multitouch GarageBand and iMovie (expanded from the iPhone's trimming) as well as am iWeb 2.0 or iBlog that allowed for simple blog and micro-blog text, photos, and movie posting.

websitewidgets_img_20090106

Conclusion

So that's TiPb's top five iApps we'd still like to see added to the iPad, iPod touch, and iPhone. Agree, disagree, or have alternatives or additions all your own? It's still 2 months to the iPad's debut at the end of March, and 6 month until we likely get the final release of iPhone 4.0, so let us -- and Apple -- know what you think!

Rene Ritchie

Editor-in-Chief of iMore, co-host of Iterate, Debug, Review, The TV Show, Vector, ZEN & TECH, and MacBreak Weekly podcasts. Cook, grappler, photon wrangler. Follow him on Twitter and Google+.

More Posts

 

0
loading...
0
loading...
3
loading...
0
loading...

← Previously

iHarmonix Platinum i-Series stereo earphones for iPhone

Next up →

Fox News: AT&T Outbid Everyone on iPad, Verizon Still in Talks over iPhone, iPad

There are 28 comments. Add yours.

Greg Braddock says:

I personally don't wanna see most of my friends in purpose so iChat is not a feature that concerns me.
I'll take iMags and multitasking and I'm good to go, I'm really easy to please.

Greg Braddock says:

I meant see most of my friends in person.

tyler says:

iWant Apple and others to stop using the 'i' prefix. It's so 2002.

joeblow84 says:

iWant to stop seeing iPad articles pretending to be iPhone articles in iPhone blogs. iThanks.

bleedingblu says:

iMags are cool! I'm pretty excited to see what else the iPad could do. I always wondered how anyone could lug this thing around but I found a site that is making custom leather carrying pouches for the iPad. No pics are up yet but they are saying around March they'll be show cased. I guess around the time the iPad goes to market. Either way here is the site http://www.mycustomleather.com

Blake0767 says:

iWant people like Rebo to quit complaining. Every post on the ipad we're going to hear from these babies.

Milk says:

iAgree @ Rebo, GTFO the iPad uses the iPhone OS.

Rene Ritchie says:

TiPb will be covering the iPhone OS platform including iPad. Not a big deal.
Rene Ritchie
Sent from my iPhone

Jellotime91 says:

@Rene Ritchie:
LOL.. that was amazing.

MrAnonymous says:

The only feature I want is the ability to hide or delete stock apps on the iPhone without having to jailbreak to do so. Here's hoping for 4.0!

Anthony says:

@robo, what's worse, you coming here and being annoyed by iPad articles or us having to deal with a nitwit that doesn't understand that no one forces him to come here to read iPad articles?

istop says:

i agree with taylor. less i-something naming conventions. i mean seriously how do you put on a straight face and say "i got this ibook from the ibookstore on my ipad, but i really wish they had imags too"

rokozumi says:

How about being able to tether my iphone to my iPad for free, or for a reduced rate.... I mean heck its the same data with the same restrictions that the iphone has, seems like it should be reasonable. I want to consider this as an alternative to buying the ipad with it's own 3G built in.... after all, I already have a very capable 3G device that is always with me.

jasonact says:

I have to think that Newspaper and especially magazines will be making their way onto the iPad before long. That just seems like a natural application of the device. Although I want an iPad for other reasons, its use as an ebook reader is very unappealing to me because of the lack of an E-Ink screen. I could definitely see myself using this to read full color magazines. That's a frequent complaint with magazines on traditional ereaders, and the iPad is perfectly positioned to overcome that complaint.
I also agree that a robust blogging client would be great. Apple's software can be hit or miss, but I wish they would at least take a stab at it.
I've never used IM, though. It just isn't useful to me, so mobile iChat doesn't appeal to me, but I can see those who use it wanting a native solution.

jmadara says:
  1. iComics

I spend about $20-$30 a month on comic books that end up in a box in the closet. I would love to see Marvel and DC release same day subscriptions to the iPad. For all you haters out there the iPad is perfect for comics. No need to pan or zoom around since it is roughly the same size as a comic. Marvel already has much of their catalog online now. They have a deal with the PSP (dumb), but the iPad would rock.

Frank says:

Magazines and newspapers are actually what I think I would use the iPad for the most. I think it'll be that thing I take a look at during commercials. I can see it replacing the pile of magazines sitting around.
Also, @rebo and @milk, stop complaining about iPad articles on an iPhone site. Given that they share an OS, I think iPad articles here are fine. Otherwise I'd have to go to some other site for iPad news. I like the one-stop-shopiness of TiPb.

joeblow84 says:

OK! OK! iStand corrected, and iStipulate that the iPad warrants coverage here since it's running the iPhone iOS. I'm just disappointed because I was hoping for it to run something more akin to the Mac OS. Here's to iRev2!

Glenn#IM says:

That is a good point on news and mags. Look what happened to music.

flyingember says:

Madara- the app is called Comics

PLAYA says:

When u update to 3.1.3 look at the battery percentage remember it, then reset ur iPhone and when it turns back on look at the 1st intial lockscreen the battery percentage will be 8% lower then after a sec it will jump back 8 % to wut it should really be… Very very strange I thought apple was supposed to fix the issue not make it worse…. DO NOT UPGRADE PLEASE STICK WITH 3.1.2 FAR LESS BUGGY….
I AM LOOSING FAITH IN APPLE UR GETTING WORSE EVERYDAY, UR NOT IMPROVING THE IPHONE UI AT ALL.. UNLIKE ALL UR COMPETITION…. STEP UP APPLE AND BE A MAN !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ParishYoung says:

I think the problems comes from Apple's own software development agreement thing.
If developers are not allowed to recreate software that is built into the iPhone OS (web browser, email client, etc) then it wouldn't be fair for Apple to make an RSS Feed Reader, Chat Client (it would look the same as messages on iPhone anyway), or Blogging tool (unless specifically for iWeb sites).
And I'm sure Apple would rather let others do it and take 30% of the cost.
iMags and iNews are intersting idea's though.
I wonder how we're going to get those fancy concepts for Magazines we saw in the run up to Jan 27th event. Also, would it just be a constantly updating App, a clever website, or what? Maybe content similar to iTunes LP I suppose.

Jeremy says:

iMags is a very interesting idea. SI's demo mag shows the potential for publishers. Earlier this week content publisher Pressmart also announced its support for iPad, which could mean something. I prefer my daily news in paper, but iMags could be new super app

Donte Helfenbein says:

Hi, I can’t understand how to add your site in my rss reader. Can you Help me, please

muck says:

Just a few apps that do some of the above. Of the 110 apps on my iPhone, I spend about 95% of the time in these three:
1) iFeeds -> I don't see how any RSS feed reader could work faster, smoother and be as well organized as MobileRSS. It integrates well with other apps, too.
2) iBlog -> I mobile blog via Blogpress. Much more robust than any other blogging apps I've found.
3) iChat -> Using MessageNow to text for free! Not as robust as a desktop chat client, but gets the job done and has push notification so you don't have to sit in the app waiting for messages.

games says:

DO you like the you tube video about this?

Schedule says:

You you could change the webpage title iChat, iMags, iNews, iFeeds, and iBlog — TiPb’s Top 5 iPad and iPhone iWants! | TiPb to more specific for your blog post you create. I loved the post nevertheless.

small washer and dryer says:

I couldn't agree more with the author. This information is valuable to me and I'll be bookmarking this blog. Keep up the good work!