Time to upgrade! Get an iPhone 12 mini + Unlimited Data for $60/mo

  • Forums
  • Shop
  • CES 2021
  • iPhone 12
  • Best VPN
  • iOS 14
  • Nintendo Switch
  • AirPods Pro
No injuction

Judge says that Epic's lawsuit against Apple should go to trial by jury

The battle rages on, and will seem to go until at least 2021.
Joe Wituschek
28 Sep 2020

Free FortniteSource: Epic Games

What you need to know

  • Epic v. Apple had a hearing today about Epic's request for a preliminary injunction.
  • Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers seems unlikely to grant such a request.
  • The judge recommended that the case goes to trial by jury, with a potential July 2021 court date.

Reported by MacRumors, Epic seems unlikely to win its request for a preliminary injunction in its lawsuit against Apple. Today, Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers, who is overseeing the case, declined to order Apple to permit Fortnite back into the App Store without complying to the rules currently set forth by the company.

When Epic attempted to argue against Apple's 30% App Store fee, Judge Rogers pointed out that every other platform, including Google Play, Xbox, and Playstation, charge the same rate.

Epic Game continued to argue that Apple has an App Store monopoly and charges excessive fees, but the judge pointed out that the 30 percent rate that Apple collects is the "industry rate" collected by PlayStation, Xbox, Nintendo, Amazon, Walmart, Best Buy, Google, and more. "It's all 30 percent and you just want to gloss over it," the judge said to Epic's lawyers. In response, Epic claimed that consoles are "different" because the hardware is sold at a loss, but the judge was unconvinced. "There doesn't seem to be evidence supporting what you're saying," she said.

Apple, in response to Epic's desire to build its own store within Apple's App Store, says that the company does not permit this in order to protect the "safety, security, and privacy of its users."

Epic said that it wants to create its own store to distribute apps on iOS, but Apple's anticompetitive behavior prohibits it. In response, Apple's lawyers said the request was an indictment of Apple's "entire business model" focused on the "safety, security, and privacy of its users."

Judge Rogers, concerning Epic's request for an injunction that would allow Fortnite back into the App Store, says that the court does not provide injunctions for contractual disputes, which she believes Epic's case against Apple to be.

She also reiterated that Epic Games made a "calculated decision" to defy Apple's App Store rules, and the court doesn't provide injunctions for contractual disputes. Epic was "not forthright," she said. "There are people in the public who consider you guys heroes for what you did, but it's not honest."

In closing, Judge Rogers recommended that the case should go to trial by jury. If it does, the case is expected to be heard by July of 2021. If you want a play-by-play of today's hearing, check out Patrick McGee, a correspondent from the Financial Times, who posted a detailed thread on Twitter:

Apple-Epic hearing started a few minutes early. "We are going to be hear for hours, I suspect," says Judge Gonzales, who threatens to mute people if they regurgitate arguments she's already aware of.

Thread begins...

— Patrick McGee (@PatrickMcGee_) September 28, 2020
Apple releases new limited-edition Apple Watch Series 6 Black Unity
a surprise release

Apple releases new limited-edition Apple Watch Series 6 Black Unity

Apple has just released a brand new limited-edition Apple Watch Series 6 to celebrate Black History Month.

Taron Egerton to star in new Apple TV+ show 'In with the Devil'
TV+

Taron Egerton to star in new Apple TV+ show 'In with the Devil'

A new report says Taron Egerton will star in a new Apple TV+ series called 'In with the Devil' alongside Paul Walter Hauser.

iPhone 12 Pro camera supplier LG sees 43% revenue rise in 2020
bumper year

iPhone 12 Pro camera supplier LG sees 43% revenue rise in 2020

iPhone 12 Pro camera supplier LG InnoTek saw its 2020 revenue rise by 43% on the previous year thanks to the iPhone 12's launch in October.

Love Fortnite? You need these Funko Pop! figures in your life
Victory royale!

Love Fortnite? You need these Funko Pop! figures in your life

Epic Games’ Fortnite has become a gaming and cultural phenomenon buoyed significantly by the Battle Royale craze. With such a meteoric rise, it’s only fitting Fortnite clashes with Funko Pop!

Keep in Touch

Sign up now to get the latest news, deals & more from iMore!

I would like to receive news and offers from other Future brands.

I would like to receive mail from Future partners.

No spam, we promise. You can unsubscribe at any time and we'll never share your details without your permission.

  • News
  • Fortnite

Joe Wituschek

Joe Wituschek has been in the technology industry for over a decade. Formerly Apple, Joe now covers the company as a news writer for iMore. Connect with Joe on Twitter @joewituschek.

  • iPhone
  • iPad
  • Apple Watch
  • Apple TV
  • Mac
  • Reviews
  • How To
  • HomeKit
  • Forums

Other Categories

  • About Us
  • Newsletter
  • Fitness
  • Apps
  • Gaming
  • Deals
  • Advertising Inquiries
  • Licensing and Reprints
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Android Central
  • Windows Central
  • CrackBerry
  • Thrifter
  • TechnoBuffalo
  • MrMobile
Log in or Sign up
  • t
  • f
  • y
  • i
  • r

Brightness

  • © Future US, Inc.
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Careers
  • Licensing
  • External Links Disclosure
  • Accessibility Statement
  • © Future US, Inc.
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Careers
  • Licensing
  • External Links Disclosure
  • Accessibility Statement