Apple TV 4K review: Come for the 4K, stay for the HDR

Best Apple TV of 2021
Best Apple TV of 2021 (Image credit: iMore)

I remember the first time I saw DVD. Same with 720p and 1080p HD. It was like putting on a fresh pair of glasses, seeing the blur and smear fade, and the world resolve better and sharper before me. I remember the first time I saw 3D as well but only because I disliked it intensely. 4K I don't really remember. I was either too far away or the set was smaller than a wall so I couldn't really see the difference. HDR (high dynamic range), though? My eyeballs are still in nirvana.

While the new set-top box is called Apple TV 4K (opens in new tab), it's really Apple TV HDR to me. That's how important I really find those more vivid colors and more expansive gamma.

See at Amazon (opens in new tab)

It's why, the moment the new Apple TV 4K was announced, I rushed out and spent a couple years worth of unused vacation money on an LG C7P OLED 4K HDR television (opens in new tab). And why I'm so deliriously happy I did.

See more on Streaming TV at!

Apple TV 4K 4K and HDR

4K (a reference to "horizontal resolution in the order 4,000 pixels") is sometimes also called UHD (ultra high definition). That's to distinguish it from regular old HD, which is 720p or 1080p (720 or 1080 vertical dots of resolution.) In that context, 4K is 2160p (2160 vertical dots of resolution) — twice the height and width, for a combined total of four times the resolution of 1080p.

Apple TV

Apple TV (Image credit: iMore)

If the content is really 4K (more on that later), and you're sitting close or your panel is really big, you can absolutely see the difference. The level of detail is simply beyond anything you've seen before. It's when 4K is combined with HDR, though, that magic happens.

If you're familiar with HDR photography on iPhone, that's what you're getting with HDR video: Instead of whites and blacks that are blown out or clipped off, you can suddenly see into all the highlights and shadows.

If you're familiar with DCI-P3 wide gamut color on recent iOS and Mac devices, that's what you're getting in HDR vide as well: Brighter and deeper reds and magentas, and more vivid greens and yellows.

Apple has even redone the tvOS interface in DCI-P3 so it looks great as you navigate for content as well. Also, the aerial screensavers that come built into the box. They've never looked more jaw-dropping. Thanks to 4K, you can almost see the people on the streets (I know that guy!). Thanks to HDR, you can almost feel the arctic sunset.

For movies and television, it's like you're watching everything again for the first time, even if you've already seen them a dozen times or more. They're dazzling. Almost as though they're bursting off the screen.

To keep all of this simple, even though people will have all sorts of different televisions with different displays preferences, Apple TV 4K and tvOS manage the picture entirely. That means, regardless of whether you have 4K or HDR, or if the content you're watching in HD or 4K, HDR 10 or Dolby Vision, Apple always picks the best possible output to send to your television.

It's great for mainstream customers who don't want or need to worry about choosing arcane numbers off a list a dozen or more items long. It's not so great for nerds who want to manage everything last aspect themselves. (Or for some content that Apple's not doing such a great job optimizing for output.)

If memory serves, once upon a time, the older Apple TV models had a screen output selector you could reach through a Konami code-like button combo. It'd be great if Apple could add that back.

You should also make sure you have an HDMI 2 cable. I really wish Apple would include one in the box, especially given the Apple TV 4K price point. But they don't. And your ratty old HDMI cable may be fine but when you're spending this much on a box and a TV, you might as well get a proper cable to go along with it. (I like the Belkin Ultra High-Speed HDMI cable (opens in new tab)

Otherwise, all you have to do to really enjoy Apple TV 4K is turn off motion and compression smoothing, and the other terrible image destroyers that come set by default on many modern televisions. And enjoy.

Apple TV 4K iTunes 4K HDR and other content

I've heard it said that the iTunes encoding team are… exacting to say the least. So, it should come as no surprise that iTunes in HDR 10 or Dolby Vision — the studio gets to decide which, if either, it uses — looks flabbergastingly good.

Now, not all content is shot or mastered for released in 4K. A lot of it, including recent blockbusters, is still shot somewhere between 2K and 4K. In those cases, the studio upscales to 4K for home video release. The quality of the upscaling can vary but it's never as good as native 4K.

iTunes 4K HDR launched alongside the Apple TV 4K, so it's only just begun coming online now. It's more than I expected but we'll have to see how that continues over time. Because it looks so good I just don't want to watch non-HDR versions anymore.

Apple has also managed to negotiate two really smart concessions from most of the studios:

  1. 4K HDR content will cost the same as the previous, HD content.
  2. Any HD movies you've already bought will be automagically upgraded to 4K HDR when those versions arrive — at no additional cost.

Disney, traditional ally of Apple and owner of roughly 80% of my childhood thanks to its own classic characters and the acquisition of Muppets, Marvel, and Star Wars, is the lone holdout. It's incredibly frustrating to me as a consumer and I hope they reconsider. In the meantime, no 4K HDR Star Wars or Marvel Studios movies for us.

iTunes 1080p content still looks pretty good, thanks to Apple's upscaling. The end of Guardians of the Galaxy 2, for example, is beautiful on Apple TV 4K. But you're still going to want as much of the real thing as you can get — and your ISP's bandwidth cap, if any, can handle. (Because of advances in HEVC/H.265 compression, 4K videos are four times the resolution but only two times the file size. Adjust your data plan or viewing habits accordingly.)

Netflix has updated to provide 4K HDR to Apple TV 4K as well, and that includes all the Marvel shows like Daredevil, Jessica Jones, and Defenders. And seeing those shows in HDR is a revelation — what was drab and blotted out before is now comic-book bright and detailed. The intro to Jessica Jones, for example, is stunning.

Amazon, as soon as it figures out how to use the incredibly simple frameworks Apple released to developers way back in 2015 and actually release a tvOS app, will bring even more HDR content to the box as well.

YouTube doesn't currently support 4K in the HEVC codec, and Apple TV 4K doesn't currently support Google's VP9 codec, which means YouTube on Apple TV is stuck at 1080p. VP9 is an open codec, though, so Apple could add support for it at some point, or Google to start encoding in HEVC. Either way, right now, it's their mutual users who are losing out.

Happily, you can use Siri to quickly and easily find everything that is available. Just ask for "4K" or "4K HDR" and you'll see everything available.

You can also use Apple's TV app, now available not just in the U.S. but in Australia, Canada, France, Germany, Norway, Sweden, and the UK as well.

Apple TV 4K Siri Remote

The Siri Remote — still called Apple Remote in all countries beyond the 12 currently offering Siri support on Apple TV — has received a minor hardware update: The menu button now has a white, raised ring around it.

Apple TV Siri Remote

Apple TV Siri Remote (Image credit: iMore)

It's not my favorite.

Siri Remote has an incredibly tough job. It has to provide control for not only the video functions of Apple TV, but apps and games as well. Adding the touch area solved a lot of problems and introduced some familiarity and consistency with iOS multitouch controls. It also avoided the problem that plagues every other multipurpose controller on the market: death by a bazillion buttons.

But it still feels like Apple's industrial design team could do more. Something that would make a raised white ring unnecessary.

Luckily, if you have an iPhone, you can use that to control Apple TV, and more easily than ever: Simply swipe up (or down on iPhone X) to invoke Control Center, then 3D Touch to pop up the new, built-in Apple TV remote interface.

You have to add the button to Control Center in Settings but, once you do, it's incredibly convenient. Even when you haven't necessarily lost your Siri Remote in the sofa cushions.

Apple TV 4K A10X

At the heart of the new Apple TV 4K is the Apple A10X Fusion system-on-a-chip. It's the same chip that's found inside the current-generation iPads Pro, and a graphically more powerful version of the chip inside iPhone 7.

In other words, it's a monster. Whatever other comparisons you want to make with competing set-top boxes, none of them come close to Apple's silicon. None are even in the same multiverse.

A10X is what gives Apple support for hardware accelerated 10-bit HEVC (H.265), which is the industry standard format for 4K HDR. But it's also what makes apps so responsive and will enable a new generation of gaming experiences on the box.

Apple dropped the ball, badly, by requiring Siri Remote support for all games on the original Apple TV and tvOS platform. It caused a lot of big studios and big games to take a wait-and-see attitude that persisted long after Apple, smartly, changed the policy. Getting those studios to stop waiting and start shipping remains a challenge. Hopefully, giving them the power of A10X combined with the ease of iOS to tvOS development will help tap the huge potential of Apple TV 4K.

(I'm not sure how many developers will take advantage of 4K HDR gaming and, frankly, how many need to given how good 1080p gaming already looks, but I'm super eager to find out!)

A10X does make Apple TV 4K seems ludicrously overpowered, though. It makes me wonder what else Apple has planned for the box?

Apple TV 4K Miscellany

Apple TV 4K has gigabit ethernet so you get faster transfer speeds if you choose to go wired. If you go wireless instead, you get simultaneous dual-band Wi-Fi so what you watch is never slowed down by whatever else you're doing at the same time.

The USB-C port on the back of the previous generation Apple TV is gone on Apple TV 4K. That means, like Apple Watch, if anything goes terribly wrong and you get stuck in recovery mode, you have to call AppleCare or go to an Apple Store for service. No more plugging into iTunes. (If you're a developer, power user, or simply brave, you can connect wirelessly to Apple's Xcode app now and try your luck there first.)

I'm not sure how I feel about this. I know it's the future and every manufacturer seems to be racing to ditch as many potential points of hardware failure as possible, but there's something to be said for the old, Battlestar-style hardwire connections. I guess I'll have to see how this goes.

Apple TV 4K can automatically switch between light and dark modes at dawn and dusk. There's still no way to extinguish the LED light on the front of the box in Settings, though. I get why, since it provides important visual information, but it remains annoying in a dark room. (Electrical tape is your friend.)

If you have multiple Apple TVs 4K in your home or office, and they're all logged into the same iCloud account, your Apple TV home screen can be set to sync between them.

AirPods will now automatically connect to any Apple TV that's on the same iCloud account as your iPhone, just like they've been doing with iPad, Apple Watch, and Mac for the last year. (Apple previously wasn't sure how to handle a personal device connecting with what could be a family device, but it looks like the simplest solution won.)

Sound remains the same at Dolby 7.1 and, even though I don't have a Dolby ATMOS system, I wish it had been included here as well. Apple, apparently, will be supporting ATMOS in a coming update. (Which makes you wonder why it didn't make it into the launch build?)

tvOS 11, which powers Apple TV 4K, now has support for right-to-left languages, including Arabic and Hebrew. There's also support for more than 70 types of refreshable braille displays.

Apple TV 4K Conclusion

There are cheaper 4K boxes on the market and some have been announced with HDR support now as well. 4K HDR televisions also typically come with built-in Netflix, Amazon Prime, and other apps for streaming 4K HDR. None of them have iTunes or the App Store, or Apple's A10X processor, but they also don't have Apple TV 4K's price tag.

Typically, Apple brings computers to gadget fights, and differentiated experiences to spec and cost comparisons. That's still true with Apple TV 4K. The difference is, people may not be as willing to pay a premium on TV boxes the way they are phones, watches, tablets, and laptops. And certainly not when the premium TV box is missing features like Dolby ATMOS at launch.

If you look at Apple TV's path from 2010 to 2017 and compare it to iPhone and iPads during the same period — or even Apple watch from 2015 to 2017 — it's clear the same level of decisiveness, focus, and product vision hasn't been present. Part of that might be attributable to the intransigence of Hollywood. But, ultimately, it's Apple's box.

And Apple will have to show its value by pushing out more and better 4K HDR content than anyone else, and providing a better experience via the TV app for Netflix (which is currently boycotting it), Amazon Prime (which has yet to ship on it), and all the other network and — coming soon, live — than the competition. They'll also have to show the value of the A10X processor by getting compelling apps and jaw-dropping games onto the platform.

For now, if you have or will soon be getting a 4K or 4K HDR television, and you're all in on iTunes and the App Store, you owe it to your eyes and experience to get Apple TV 4K. Nothing else can do what it can do, not at any price. And the picture quality is so much better you won't ever want to go back. Everything else is nice. But the 4K HDR picture is transformative.

See at Amazon (opens in new tab)

Rene Ritchie

Rene Ritchie is one of the most respected Apple analysts in the business, reaching a combined audience of over 40 million readers a month. His YouTube channel, Vector, has over 90 thousand subscribers and 14 million views and his podcasts, including Debug, have been downloaded over 20 million times. He also regularly co-hosts MacBreak Weekly for the TWiT network and co-hosted CES Live! and Talk Mobile. Based in Montreal, Rene is a former director of product marketing, web developer, and graphic designer. He's authored several books and appeared on numerous television and radio segments to discuss Apple and the technology industry. When not working, he likes to cook, grapple, and spend time with his friends and family.

  • Right....but no 4K YouTube and at least $80 more than a 4K HDR Roku box? Plus no Disney 4K support on iTunes...what makes this worth it for you in comparison to other boxes out there? I’m asking because I’m in the market.
  • The fact that the Roku box also supports Dolby Atmos makes the Apple TV even less appealing. The only thing I'm drawn to at the moment is the price parity between HD and 4K movies on iTunes (Disney's non commitment notwithstanding).
  • I’m really disappointed about not having Disney on board. I was looking forward to an upgrade of my Disney titles (all of my purchased movies are basically Disney titles).
  • what sucks is two different HDR formats! I have a samsung which uses HDR 10 so all the movies in dolby vision will just be 4k no HDR
  • Wrong. All Dolby Vision mastered content also supports HDR10. However, HDR10 mastered content does not support Dolby Vision. Also, the Dolby Vision library so far is small when compared to HDR10. Only Vudu so far has a limitation where they only support Dolby Vision and not HDR10, though that too is supposed to change. Of course, Vudu doesn’t matter in this case as it is much cheaper to buy 4K content from Apple.
  • I’ve heard this and also that it’s not this way I hope your right! This is two different formats it’s not just hdr 10 vs hdr 12 I think it’s like two totally different things I don’t know
  • It is definitely how I stated above. The *only* service that breaks this rule is Vudu. On Apple TV all Dolby Vision content will default to HDR10 if the TV is not capable of Dolby Vision.
  • thanks this would be perfect!
  • We haven’t upgraded out HDTVs to 4k so I don’t see any benefits to purchasing the new Apple TV. Other than 4k I don’t see any difference between the two.
  • Thanks captain obvious.
  • It’s not necessary obvious. Some could think there are other features or benefits. There aren’t in my opinion.
  • My question is, can I download the 4K HDR content to my iPhone 8 Plus and then stream that in 4K HDR quality to my Apple TV 4K via Airplay? I still have only DSL at home, so streaming 4K HDR is not an option.
  • Anyone know if the version of Goodfellas I bought (with the iTunes extras) is available in 4k? As there are currently 2 copies on iTunes and the one being advertised on their 4k page is not the one I bought.
  • I am so excited to get my Apple TV <3
  • I'm not sure on this. I've heard it's not so good with the 4k upconverting, and you can't turn it off. My TV does a good job of that, I bought it partly because of that, I don't need Apple to do that for me too.
  • OVERPRICED, and late to the party.
  • I was looking at my 4th Gen apple TV, and all the movies in my collection are saying they're 4k. was this just a software update, or do I need to purchase the new apple TV 4k in order to get the full advantage of the 4K HDR?
  • @Rene Ritchie, you are wrong on this, "Apple always picks the best possible output to send to your television." Currently the Apple TV 4k default to 4k HDR ONLY. If the movie supports dolby vision it will NOT switch over and if you are playing a 1080p movie it will automatically up convert to 4k which is not good because the image quality would be grainy. Hopefully, Apple will push a new firmware/software so it'll automatically select the "Correct" format. And for other folks who are out in the market to buy a STB and getting into Home Automation I would recommend buying the 4th gen or 5th gen Apple TV that way you can control all of your Homekit accessories remotely. That is the key difference between Roku, Amazon FireTV and Chrome stick they do not offer any remote control of your home automation.