Dogfight review: The war between Apple and Google gets personal

Dogfight review: The war between Apple and Google

Dogfight: How Apple and Google Went to War and Started a Revolution by Fred Vogelstein is a tale of two companies, two of the most important of the current era, how they both started working on phone projects, and how it not only destroyed their friendships, but eventually the careers of many involved. Much of it is already well known. Google, worried that Microsoft would dominate phones the way they had desktops, and shut them down the way Netscape had been shut down, bought Andy Rubin's company, Android, and set about making a Windows Mobile/BlackBerry/Nokia communicator competitor. Apple, meanwhile adapted their stalled tablet project into the iPhone. And that's when it gets interesting...

Eric Schmidt, Larry Page, and Sergei Brin of Google, apparently, didn't tell Andy Rubin that Vic Gundotra had been secretly working with Apple to make sure Google services were front and center on the iPhone. Rubin found out when the world did, when Steve Jobs took to the Macworld stage in 2007 and showed off the iPhone. Rubin realized at that moment the current version of Android was already obsolete, but he also saw weaknesses in the iPhone, and a way to beat it.

Meanwhile, Eric Schmidt, Larry Page, and Sergei Brin had also kept Steve Jobs and Apple in the dark about Android, downplaying its importance to them, saying it wouldn't compete with the iPhone, and claiming they weren't sure it would ever become a releasable product. Meanwhile a confluence of carriers and manufacturers, now reeling to compete with Apple, were suddenly incredibly receptive to Rubin and what would become the all-new Android.

As it became evident Android would indeed compete with the iPhone, Steve Jobs became livid. A meeting happened, recounted almost as dark matter - by its consequences. At Jobs' insistence, they pulled multitouch gestures from Android, and made the unlock more complicated. It was then Rubin's turn rage, incredulous that Google had caved in to what he considered Apple's ridiculous demands. He needn't have worried - the capitulation didn't last long, and soon Motorola, HTC, Samsung, and other devices shipped as full on competitors to the iPhone, and Android's market share exploded.

The war had begun.

Vogelstein tells the tale well, switching points of view between the two companies and their projects, yet weaving the elements together inexorably together. There are plenty of great stories - the archeology of modern consumer electronics - which I love. And the account stays balanced, portraying both companies and both sides not in stark black and white, good and evil terms, but as people and businesses that saw the future and did what they had to claim it.

The beginning of Dogfight: How Apple and Google Went to War and Started a Revolution is better than the end. It loses steam towards the end as events become both more recent and less impactful, and as Vogelstein turns from recounting the story to filling in some of his own ideas on where the various industries are headed. I read the early chapters, wrapped. The last few, I ended up skimming.

Overall Vogelstein does a great job telling a good tale. That it's a fairly well-known tale within the industry doesn't matter, there's enough color to more than hold its own. From how Rubin persevered in getting Android to market, to how iPhone engineers took shots during the Macworld Keynote, it will likely appeal to readers of iMore and Mobile Nations alike. Whether you're head-over-heels in love with iPhone, or totally in love with Android, Vogelstein's book will add tons of perspective and a healthy dose of nuance to the story of both.

I enjoyed it, and recommend it. Grab it now on iBooks or Kindle.

Have something to say about this story? Leave a comment! Need help with something else? Ask in our forums!

Rene Ritchie

EiC of iMore, EP of Mobile Nations, Apple analyst, co-host of Debug, Iterate, Vector, Review, and MacBreak Weekly podcasts. Cook, grappler, photon wrangler. Follow him on Twitter and Google+.

More Posts



← Previously

Doctor Who: The Day of the Doctor now available on iTunes!

Next up →

Instagram reportedly getting into the insta-messaging game

Reader comments

Dogfight review: The war between Apple and Google gets personal


Be friends, do no evil... But play both sides the whole time so you can make a bunch of money from advertising.
-Google's business method. -

Sent from the iMore App

Isn't it time that nerds & geeks had their own soap opera? This sounds alike a good start.

Sent from the iMore App

It's an interesting story but we've definitely heard most of it before. At least by using an iPhone and iPad I feel like I get Google's services almost as good as those found on android but I get the Apple quality hardware.

I'll just wait til somebody adapts this into a movie. Thank you.
On a serious note, I think reading this kind of material would have made more impact if they had waited a couple more years before they released it.

Sent from the iMore App

Look at the savings by getting the Kindle version'
It looks like an interesting read, definitely on my wish list!

Sent from the iMore App

Does the iBooks version have something extra, like interactive content? Besides I can't seem to be able to buy the kindle version of the book it shows 'book not available for purchase'. Anyone having the same problem?

Great. Added to my Amazon wish list for Christmas. Still haven't gone the route of reading ebooks though. iPhone screen is too small and the Mac is a not fun to read on.

I want this and the Jony Ive book.

Sent from the iMore App

Definitely sounds interesting, it's a shame it loses impact (perhaps due to lack of recent sources?) But as someone who uses both systems I'm sure I'd enjoy it. It's certainly a fascinating story that has yet to have many chapters written. :-)

Sent from the iMore App

The worlds seem to be splitting apart in more places than they're coming together. I hope Apple let's Google back in on some more native control into their iOS platform instead of all these pseudo workarounds.

Sent from the iMore App