US appeals court finds in favor of Apple over Motorola patent row, upholding ITC ruling

US appeals court finds in favor of Apple over Motorola patent row, upholding ITC ruling

Apple does not use technology patented by Google's Motorola Mobility business unit in the iPhone, a federal appeals court said on Friday. The decision upholds a ruling made by the International Trade Commission (ITC) last April, according to Reuters.

Apple, Google, Samsung and others have been in pitched in worldwide legal battles over the technology used in their mobile devices as the companies stake out claims. In 2010 (prior to its acquisition by Google), Motorola Mobility claimed that Apple infringed six of its patents. The ITC ruled in favor of Apple. Predictably, Motorola Mobility appealed, and the appeals court again found in Apple's favor, at least for one of the six patents, according to the report.

Motorola Mobility has a large amount of patents to its credit, and it was one of Google's principal reasons for acquiring the business unit to begin with. So it's got to smart a little bit for Google to find out that at least some of these patents aren't providing it with the ammunition it needs to keep Apple at bay.

It'd be nice if everyone could play together without bloodying noses, but that's not going to happen: companies competing in the same markets with similar products have long sought to disrupt each others' businesses by dragging them into court. A lot of people are plainly exhausted by it, and there's a lot of call for patent law reform. Certainly it's needed.

Patent reform has been been on the mind of legislators in the US Congress lately; in December, the House of Representatives passed the Innovation Act (one of the few pieces of legislation, it seems, that was widely favored by both parties). The act - now in the hands of the Senate - would make it more difficult for so-called patent trolls to operate. Patent trolls aren't companies like Apple and Google, but businesses like Lodsys, which make no products but instead has targeted small iOS and Android app developers for legal action, alleging that they violate patents on things like in-app purchases.

That won't solve the bigger problem - that many, many patents have been granted to companies and individuals for only vaguely-worded and vaguely-described inventions. Getting to the root that problem is going to require a fundamental overhaul of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, and I haven't heard the right people talk about that particular issue at all.

Source: Reuters

Have something to say about this story? Leave a comment! Need help with something else? Ask in our forums!

Peter Cohen

Mac Managing Editor of iMore and weekend Apple Product Professional at a local independent Apple reseller. Follow him on Twitter @flargh

More Posts



← Previously

Weekly Photo Contest: Technology and electronics!

Next up →

#CESlive: Qardio brings health monitoring solutions to the masses

Reader comments

US appeals court finds in favor of Apple over Motorola patent row, upholding ITC ruling


"Getting to the roof that problem... "
Did you mean "getting to the root"?

Nice read. I see that 1/6 patents were decided upon so this will be quite ongoing, yes?
Would everyone's truly be better w/out all this patent hub-bub?

Sent from the iMore App

Glad it was in Mavericks. I almost suggested you use the new "Typo" keyboard lol

Sent from the iMore App

I get auto corrected for so much, and half the time it's seemingly based on anticipated expressions. It completely makes me look like a doof!
...Well, I suppose I do that well enough on my own, but I certainly don't need any assistance with it!

Enjoyed the story. Each of these companies are just trying to protect their intellectual property. So these things will continue. It's business and nothing personal.

Sent from the iMore App