Best Breast Pumps iMore 2019

The world of breast pumps is huge, and there isn't one shining breast pump star that works for absolutely every Mom. To find the best pumps for this list, we've taken into consideration electric vs. manual, let-down and expression techniques, portable vs. stationary, and the ability to be completely hands-free. We feel that the Spectra Baby S1 is best overall for its customizable modes and closed system.

Best Overall: Spectra Baby S1 Breast Pump

Loved by moms and lactation consultants alike, the Spectra S1 is a rechargeable breast pump so that you can take it anywhere and everywhere. It comes with an added night light that allows you to pump at any hour and can be used as a single or double pump. The pump's digital controls allow you to set the pumping program to the speed and rhythm most effective for your body. Plus, the suction is adjustable in both letdown and expression mode. This quiet pump also includes a timer so you can track your minutes on each side or overall. The "massage mode" simulates the natural suckling of your baby, and the adjustable suction levels provide for a more natural flow of milk. This pump also features a closed system, so there's no need to clean the narrow tubing. This protects breast milk and baby from bacteria, mold, and viruses while pumping.

This pump is on the pricier side, but you get a lot of bang for your buck. Most moms agree that it is well worth the money. It comes with two 24mm and 28mm flange, so if you need any other flange size, you must order separately. Also, beware that this pump does not start in let-down mode. It automatically resumes the suction and speed you left off with via your last pump. So, make sure you switch it to letdown mode when you start so you can get the most out of each session.

Pros:

  • Rechargeable
  • Quiet
  • Customizable & adjustable let-down and expression modes
  • Closed System

Cons:

  • Pricey
  • Only comes with 24mm & 28mm flange
  • Doesn't start in let-down mode

Best Overall

Spectra Baby S1 Breast Pump

Breast with the best

This pump is rechargeable and highly rated by Moms and lactation consultants alike. We love how customizable the let down and expression settings are.

Best Manual: Bumblebee Manual Breast Pump

This manual breast pump is made of 100% food-grade silicone and is great at collecting breastmilk and relieving engorgement using pure natural suction pressure. It's extremely soft and comfortable to use and is BPA, PVC, and Phthalate free. Pro tip: Use on one breast while you nurse your baby on the other to catch any drip or flow on the opposite side. It can also be used for breast expression alone. It's very light and perfect for traveling, plus at such a low price, you can't beat it!

On the downside, the suction on this pump isn't super strong, and it's manually controlled, so you need to be fully present while expressing. This product is also not "hands-free," as you need one hand to create suction, and users report the product sometimes falling off the breast.

Pros:

  • Budget-friendly
  • BPA, PVC, & Phthalate free
  • Light, portable, and travel-friendly

Cons:

  • No super strong suction
  • Not hands-free
  • Can fall off breast

Best Manual

Bumblebee Manual Breast Pump

Manual & Travel Friendly

This is an easy to use, manual, food-grade silicone breast pump. It comes with a cute storage bag, silicone breast pump, pump lid, and pump stopper.

Best App Tracking: Medela Sonota Smart Double Electric Breast Pump

The Medela Sonota means business in when it comes to "smart" breast pumps. This double electric pump was designed with the comfort and convenience of both Mom and baby in mind. Engineered with 2-Phase Expression technology and smart capabilities, the Sonata seamlessly connects to the MyMedela app for unlimited access to your personalized dashboard. It has real-time tracking of your pumping sessions and baby's growth, and a variety of breast milk feeding resources. Plus, it includes evidence-based lactation guidance and personalized content to help you reach your breast milk feeding goals. This pump features hospital-grade performance but is ultra-quiet and discreet. It is customizable with two clinically tested pumping rhythms that allow you to choose the best pumping experience for your body.

On the downside, you're somewhat limited with only two expression modes, and this pump is very pricey. Users report the parts being heavier than other popular breast pump models.

Pros:

  • Smart capabilities
  • App tracking
  • Hospital-grade

Cons:

  • Only two expression modes
  • Pricey
  • Heavy

Best App Tracking

Medela Sonota Smart Double Electric Breast Pump

App-tastic!

This smart pump features 2-phase expression technology and app tracking that monitors each pumping session and your baby's growth.

Best Hands Free: Willow Breast Pump

The Willow breast pump is fairly new to the market. This all-in-one breast pump fits in your bra and goes anywhere you go. It uses patented, no-spill technology that lets you pump fully hands-free. Everything works inside the pump and inside your bra with no external tubes, cords, or dangling bottles to hold you back. Milk flows into the spill-proof milk bag inside of the pump. Smart, proprietary technology responds to your body and maintains suction similar to a baby, enabling true mobility without spilling a drop. This pump allows you to lie down, bend over, play with baby, take a conference call, and pump wherever the day takes you. It also connects to the Willow App for easy volume tracking, session history, and personalized pumping tips.

On the downside, this pump is costly and is not covered by insurance. Make sure this is a feasible option for your family before purchasing as your insurance company will not reimburse you. It is also quiet, not "silent."

Pros:

  • Hands-free
  • Smart capabilities
  • No-spill

Cons:

  • Pricey
  • Not covered by insurance
  • Quiet, not silent

Best Hands Free

Willow Breast Pump

Pump where life takes you

A completely hands-free, quiet, rechargeable, smart, breast pump with a one-year warranty. It features seven levels of suction and is spill-proof.

Best Budget: Lansinoh Signature Pro Double Electric Breast Pump

This double electric pump is a portable pump with an LCD screen and companion app that won't break the bank. It features a closed system design with adjustable suction levels and customizable pumping styles for maximum milk production. Its closed system design keeps breastmilk from backing up into the motor or tubing, which helps prevent mold and bacteria, and it can be used as a double or single pump. It also allows you to pump directly into Lansinoh's pre-sterilized breastmilk storage bags for convenient, hygienic pumping. It's lightweight and great for traveling!

Some users report leak issues and that this pump is very loud. Also, take note that the battery life is short, and will only last for about two or three half-hour pumping sessions.

Pros:

  • Budget-friendly
  • Rechargeable battery
  • Small, lightweight, & travel-friendly

Cons:

  • Short battery life
  • Reported leaks
  • Loud

Best Budget

Lansinoh Signature Pro Double Electric Breast Pump

Pump on a budget

This is a budget friendly double electric, rechargeable, smart, portable pump with tote bag and pumping essentials included.

Breast is best

We know that breastfeeding is a full-time job in itself and that a solid breast pump is an essential tool for the superheroes we call Moms. We've put in the research and considered the crucial qualities of a top-notch breast pump which is why we feel that the Spectra Baby S1 is the Best Breast Pump Overall.

It has rave reviews from moms and lactation consultants. It has adjustable and customizable let-down and expression modes. Plus, it has the portability and rechargeable factor. With it's quiet and lightweight nature, the Spectra Baby S1 wins the best of the best when it comes to the breast.

We may earn a commission for purchases using our links. Learn more.