Poll: If iPhone 5 gets a new US carrier, should it be T-Mobile or Sprint?

With rumors of iPhone 5 potentially adding a third US carrier, would you rather that carrier be T-Mobile or Sprint?

T-Mobile is GSM like AT&T but would require different, AWS bands for 3G. They also offer "4G" over HSPA+, which iPhone 5 just might support. However, AT&T is trying to buy them, so they might get the iPhone that way sooner or later. Sprint is CDMA like Verizon but would need access to their network. They also offer "4G" over Wimax, which Apple will probably never support because LTE will be a much bigger, more global technology. (See our wireless networking glossary for what all those letters mean.)

If you could have only one for iPhone 5, T-Mobile or Sprint, which would it be?

Rene Ritchie

Editor-in-Chief of iMore, co-host of Iterate, Debug, ZEN and TECH, MacBreak Weekly. Cook, grappler, photon wrangler. Follow him on Twitter, App.net, Google+.

More Posts



← Previously

New and updated iPhone and iPad apps for Monday, June 13

Next up →

Developer Spotlight: Kai Yu of BeeJive

There are 30 comments. Add yours.

Andrei Zaharia says:

I want factory unlocked ! :D

Retrolike says:

T-mobiles coverage & customer service sucks. They don't deserve it.

slowlane says:

I'd say the same thing about Sprint.

Myke Cox says:

So why did Sprint improve in customer service and T-Mo drop? Shouldn't say that same, no matter what your bias is, facts are facts.

TMobileiPhoneUser says:

I've been with T-Mobile U.S. for years (with my iPhone) and have to say that their customer service has been STELLAR. It's the best customer service I've had (and I've been with PacBell, Cingular, AT&T, and T-Mobile).
I'm already using the iPhone on T-Mobile right now.

TJ says:

T-Mobile has consistently gotten high marks for customer service, often ranking #1. Maybe you had a bad experience -- that happens -- but I've had 9 years of great experience with T-Mobile, and the overall ratings are consistent with great customer service.

kalafalas says:

Why would then put it on T-Mobile, in 10 months T-Mobile is becoming AT&T

sting7k says:

Tmobile, if anything for my mom. She is too loyal and will never leave Tmobile and she want's an iPhone bad.

OrionAntares#CB says:

Stupid buttons, meant to reply only.
Get her an unsubsidized iPhone and the cheaper data plan that only has 100MB of "4G" data and unlimited 2G data. The data is slow but if she wants an iPhone that badly then the data speeds probably aren't a primary concern. As pointed out above, there are people that do this already.

Chris says:

T-Mobile because it is GSM and can be used around the world. Assuming it is unlocked.

MiracleMan says:

Since T-Mobile is being absorbed by AT&T, they are technically getting it anyway. So Sprint makes the most sense to move to.

TJO3 says:

It should be on both. The iPhone should've been on all carriers since it's inception. Exclusivity like the iPhone had with AT&T is illegal in other countries. It's ridiculous and dwarfs sales. Limiting the consumer to one, bad carrier is a terrible decision. PlayStation did it again by choosing AT&T. There are many people who want the iPhone, but refuse to be locked into a carrier that they don't want. This argument is tired and shouldn't exist anymore. It's nothing but nonsense and frustration for the customers (or potential customers), especially since iOS has finally joined the world of modern mobile OSes.

Mike says:

Apple tried other carriers with the iPhone before it launched AT&T was the only us carrier that would give them a chance sprint tmobile and Verizon turned them down that's why AT&T locked them in for 4 years and now every carrier wants the iPhone because of the success it has brought AT&T and now Verizon

Duhwayne D'Zyre Reed says:

Apple has already turned down those rumors. They wanted GSM all the way.

Sin City says:

What kind of poll is that? It should be both. The point about LTE will moot for Sprint, when they announce the move this summer.

Crunch says:

T-Mobile is almost part of AT&T, so what would be the point? Sprint is the only logical choice and if Sprint does get the iPhone, it is going to be on what will be all 3 major carriers in the U.S.

teknewsworld says:

The best thing would be an unlocked iPhone which we may see on Wednesday. I hope so.

cardfan says:

I'll say Sprint if just to get those folks on board with the iphone. The more with iOS, the better features like iMessage and facetime will be.

Flintchesthair says:

I say t-mobile for the global aspect, but really it should be on both.

iDavey says:

I'd say both, but focus on the Sprint version since T-Mobile more than likely will just phase out of existence in the next year or so. Many people are already abandoning ship.

Winski says:

The current makeup and blatant disregard for what THE CUSTOMER WANTS by the current carriers AND their on-going attempt to stuff us into a 'plan', slave contract, Apple should do as the rumors speculate - UNLOCK IT and let the CUSTOMER CHOOSE !

Zsk8er1 says:

As crazy as this sounds I don't think that T-Mobile deserves any profit from the iPhone. Their only goal in commercials now are to make the iPhone look bad. At first they said things like iPhone with AT&T is too slow. Then Apple added verizon but T-Mobile still said the iPhone was slow with AT&T as if it was the only choice. And it's not even their commercial idea, they just took the idea from Apple. I say they add sprint and let T-mobile suffer because I don't think there is a carrier on the planet that wouldn't want to gain from the iPhone's profit.

OrionAntares#CB says:

They added a commercial with Verizon in it.

Zsk8er1 says:

Ok my bad. But truthfully that just makes it worse. What will they say if sprint gets on the iPhone? Will they say everyone else is slower. My point is is that they think they are top dog because they have 4G on a phone, when the phone itself is nowhere close to as functional as the phone they are making look bad. Sprint is a great choice, not T-Mobile.

Jonathan Seals says:

I think both. There should be an option for that on the poll :P

Gregz0r says:

It needs to be Sprint, just because I want an MLB At Bat-style NFL app for iOS.

Riley Freeman says:

it should depend on whether or not the merger goes through. i think you guys should have added more options or re-worded the question

OrionAntares#CB says:

Sprint is the easiest one. That's just a simple reprogramming, no extra manufacturing costs.

EagleyeSmith says:

GSM > CDMA. Though, it would be good to see sprint get in on the love.