Over the last 5 weeks of the 3rd Annual Smartphone Round Robin, the editors of our sibling sites, Casey from AndroidCentral.com, Kevin from CrackBerry.com, Matt from NokiaExperts.com, Dieter from PreCentral.net, and Phil from WMExperts.com have all had their chance to review TiPb's flagship iPhone 3GS. And we've just had to sit here and take it, the good and the bad, the raves and the rants. Well, it's week 6 now, baby, and TiPb gets to retort!
PreCentral.net's Dieter Bohn
Week 1 saw our Editor-in-Chief, Dieter Bohn, this time representing PreCentral.net, return to the iPhone he's reviewed about 5 or 6 times already, and... he was remarkably fair and I'm kind of sad there's nothing much to pick him apart over. Thanks for nothing! One of his negatives is something I've been thinking about for a while, though:
iPhone 3G was indeed a departure from the original iPhone 2G; it lost the aluminum and gained a new, curved-for-thinness form. And people got really upset their cases didn't fit any more, their docks didn't fit anymore, and accused Apple of changing just to force people to re-buy all their accessories. Then the iPhone 3GS came out, new model same as the one before, and people got really upset that it wasn't refreshed. Fashionistas complained one could tell they had the new model. Both the iPhone casing and the iPhone home screen wouldn't be hurt for an update, but Apple won't win either way.
As for Dieter's conclusion:
I'd add the mobile web to that. iPhone Safari still hasn't been exceeded and there's a reason iPhone-optimized sites are still what other mobile WebKit clients want to pull. The point itself is spot on though -- iPhone is owning the app and media space while BlackBerry owns messaging, and Android, Palm, Nokia, and WinMo battle it out over "openness" and "in-between". Multitasking we might get in a future update (iPhone 4.0?) but it's tough to see Apple loosening their ties on the App Store until and unless competition forces them to. Geeks and philosophers notwithstanding, some users and some developers prefer the level of trust a "gate-keeper"-style store provide (though Apple could certainly do better on the consistency side).
WMExperts' Phil Nickinson
Week 2 brought us Phil Nickinson, editor of WMExperts.com, and again he was frustratingly fair. He also raised some good food for thought:
I've been toying with the over-simplification that iPhone involves surrendering control to Apple in exchange for user-experience, Android involves surrendering privacy to Google in exchange for free services, and BlackBerry involves surrendering serenity to RIM in exchange for constant connectivity. There's no perfect device or perfect model; everything is a compromise, and for a large swath of users, that's a good deal. They don't want to control (or have to worry about managing) their device -- they just want to easily use it.
Actor and gadget aficionado Stephen Fry uproariously so elegantly phrased:
That the iPhone jumpstarted a complacent smartphone industry in 2007 is undeniable, as is the impact its made since. In that context, the media contrivance of "iPhone killer" makes sense. Until something makes that same original-iPhone-in-2007 level leap, it's likely the media will keep comparing everything to the iPhone. Steve Jobs was recently rumored to have said Google's Android wants to "kill" the iPhone, and likely the Windows Mobile team does as well. They have to if they want any hope to be competitive. No doubt the iPhone G4/4.0 team at Apple wants to kill the iPhone 3GS/3.0 as well. That is one of the keys to Apple's success.
AndroidCentral's Casey Chan
Week 3 had Casey Chan, editor of AndroidCentral.com share his thoughts on the iPhone 3GS, and forget the conclusion, he starts with the bang:
Our own Chad Garrett likes to say the iPhone is the first smartphone for everyone upgrading from the RAZR and there's some truth to that. With the iPhone, Apple mainstreamed the smartphone -- they took it from a power device for power users with a powerful requirement for tweaking, managing, and messing around with, and carefully packaged a subset of important features for the masses. That means that, for any particular user -- and especially for a power user -- there's a high chance that subset doesn't include an important feature.
That's Apple's modus operandi, however. They'd rather start limited and add slowly. They'd rather leave something out completely than add in something they don't think just works well enough. They're masters of always leaving something else on the table for the next update. And they're laser-focused on those features they consider essential for the user they're targeting.
And yes, it drives us all nuts, even as they've sold 70,000 devices on the iPhone OS platform and used it to familiarize everyone with the next-step in multitouch iPhone OS UI -- the iPad.
CrackBerry.com's Kevin Michaluk
Week 4 was our best frenemy forever, CrackBerry.com's own Kevin Michaluk and he embraces the same yin/yang theory about iPhone/BlackBerry as TiPb:
Kevin being Kevin, however, he can't resist tweaking us either. The Man who, in the first year called the iPhone 2G the iSmudge (before BlackBerry copied its black and silver design) and in the second year called it the Ah Frak Phone (on the eve of the BlackBerry Storm launch no less), decided this year he'd call the iPhone 3GS the douchebag phone (he owns one -- as do almost all the Smartphone Experts editors).
NokiaExperts' Matt Miller
Week 5 closed things out with NokiaExperts.com's Matt Miller, who like Dieter is a multi-handset mobile gadgeteer with a lot of experience and a global point of view. His take:
Setting aside that these are some of the most popular reasons people still Jailbreak their iPhones, Matt (and the other editors who took similar issue with iPhone functionality) will likely find many TiPb readers agreeing with him, yours truly included. Only built-in Apple apps can multitask, only your latest push message is shown on the Lock Screen (if you haven't already dismissed it), and that same one message/dismissal is the crux of the notification problem.
This brings everything sharply into focus. Apple prides itself on making software "5-years ahead of the competition" (see iPhone virtual keyboard). They would rather not provide a solution than provide one that they don't think answers the problem simply and elegantly (see cut, copy, and paste appearing only in iPhone 3.). They would rather provide a highly focused subset of functionality for the mainstream than to check off every power-user want (see everything all of us, er... want). Every version of the iPhone adds features that were considered "missing" to the previous version, either as technology and development resources allow, or Apple deems us sufficiently learned on what came before, and sufficiently motivated to buy what's next.
So, if RAM and CPU are at the level where multitasking will almost never crash the Phone app and Apple decides they have the UI for it they want, if Dashboard goes mobile but can remain uncluttered and Apple-esque in execution and DashCode joins the iPhone SDK, if... well, given the rapid rise of push notifications, there's no if -- we need better alert handling -- we just might get some or all of these things in iPhone 4.0.
Conclusion... Coming Soon
Week 6 is my turn. The iPhone 3GS comes home to TiPb and given everything every other editor has written about it, and everything I've written about the Nokia, BlackBerry, Android, Windows Phone, and Palm webOS, I have to re-examine and re-review the iPhone 3GS.
While that may not be conclusive, it will be TiPb's conclusion for this year.
Master your iPhone in minutes
iMore offers spot-on advice and guidance from our team of experts, with decades of Apple device experience to lean on. Learn more with iMore!
Rene Ritchie is one of the most respected Apple analysts in the business, reaching a combined audience of over 40 million readers a month. His YouTube channel, Vector, has over 90 thousand subscribers and 14 million views and his podcasts, including Debug, have been downloaded over 20 million times. He also regularly co-hosts MacBreak Weekly for the TWiT network and co-hosted CES Live! and Talk Mobile. Based in Montreal, Rene is a former director of product marketing, web developer, and graphic designer. He's authored several books and appeared on numerous television and radio segments to discuss Apple and the technology industry. When not working, he likes to cook, grapple, and spend time with his friends and family.